Re:Why the IRS is Targeting Open Source Software Groups
by pyre on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @10:48PM
(#5943848)
So... if "the sky is blue" is interpreted to mean, "the sky is green," we have to wait for Congress to pass a new law stating, "the sky isn't green?"
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Why the IRS is Targeting Open Source Software Groups
by jacques_chester on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @03:12AM
(#5944593)
Or you appeal to a higher court.
Law is not static. Congress or Parliament makes its legislation, ambiguity arises in corner cases, Courts are asked to sort it out. Courts try to divine the intention of Congress or Parliament. If Congress or Parliament disagree with that interpretation then yes: it's up to them to change the law. Otherwise, by failure to further Act, they conceptually support the Court's interpretation of their intent.
Re:Why the IRS is Targeting Open Source Software Groups
by Guvante on Thursday June 27, 2013 @12:09AM
(#5950693)
To be fair, the original wording was pretty bad. If a non-profit had someone pay $1 into a political fund (potentially without approval) they could lose their nonprofit status.
This is obviously not the intent of the law, but would be the 0% everyone throws around.
You could say <1% or something, but now you are arbitrarily drawing a line. Thus I would point out that not drawing a line is by extension impossible.