News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re: Snowden distributed encrypted copies of NSA docs around ... by quackerhacker on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @08:08PM (#5943293)
Just for the uninformed that may not know what your referencing.

http://www.theblaze.com/stories/2013/06/21/email-sent-by-mic...

Re: Snowden distributed encrypted copies of NSA docs around ... by tlrobinson on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @09:06PM (#5943489)
Thanks to LA's high concentration of paparazzi there's video of (allegedly) him blowing through a red light moments before the crash: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gNhqKRugk8Q as well as video of the burning wreck minutes later: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3LSY3wVuASg (possibly disturbing video)

Also, interview with an eyewitness: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fweyFCFKcp0

Re: Snowden distributed encrypted copies of NSA docs around ... by nthitz on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @09:29PM (#5943557)
Related: a presentation by DARPA about car cyberattacks http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_embedded&v=3D6jx...
Re: Snowden distributed encrypted copies of NSA docs around ... by tlrobinson on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @09:55PM (#5943642)
Re: Snowden distributed encrypted copies of NSA docs around ... by chaz on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @10:42PM (#5943827)
I spent a few min reading the referenced paper, and they do seem to demonstrate that there's the possibility of electronically compromising car electronics, including brakes.

However, steering and brakes are mechanical systems in Hastings' 2013 Mercedes C250 (like almost every other car), and cannot be electronically overridden. The steering wheel is connected directly to the wheels, and can't be controlled by the electronics. Electronics can activate the brakes, but can't cause the brakes to not activate because the pedal is connected hydraulically to the calipers. Even if the engine is racing, braking force is greater than the engine's force. [2]

If his car was vulnerable, all-electronic attack doesn't seem like a good way to assassinate someone if they can simply step on the brakes to stop the car. Changing the mechanics to allow remote control might be possible, but that's a lot of physical evidence to add to the car.

[1] http://www.autosec.org/pubs/cars-usenixsec2011.pdf [2] http://www.keacher.com/672/title-fight-brakes-versus-engine/

Re: Snowden distributed encrypted copies of NSA docs around ... by dsl on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @11:57PM (#5944107)
The Mercedes C250 (like almost all cars) has anti-lock brakes. The hydraulic (as you refer to them 'mechanical') brake cylinders are controlled by one of the cars ECUs based on data from the brake pedal, emergency brake, and rotational sensors on each wheel hub.

Everything in newer model cars is connected to the CAN bus (basically a broadcast serial protocol), radio, airbags, brakes, etc.

Your XM Satellite Radio could in theory detect that you are traveling over 70 mph and trigger just the right front brake cylinder. Any time you detect braking on other wheels, fire one of the 9 drivers side airbags to disrupt the operator.

Re: Snowden distributed encrypted copies of NSA docs around ... by Amadou on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @01:00AM (#5944286)
The C250 definitely has an option that can sort of steer just by application of the brakes on individual wheels like you described. Their marketing name for it is "active lane keeping assist."

http://www4.mercedes-benz.com/manual-cars/ba/cars/w166/en/ov...

Re: Snowden distributed encrypted copies of NSA docs around ... by chaz on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @01:01AM (#5944289)
Agree with everything you said as possibilities. There are clear proofs of concept that an accident can be caused by a compromised electronics, and multiple ways to do it. We can come up with endless possibilities, but I was trying to establish likely vs unlikely.

In his particular case, an attacker would require Hastings to be traveling at a high rate of speed to have a high probability of a fatal injury. Highland Ave is a 35 mph surface street. So the attacker would either need to speed the car up, or have him already traveling at a high rate of speed. If it's the former, Hastings could have just used the brakes. If it's the latter, there are lots of reasons why he could crash on a two-lane city street lined with trees and parked cars at 4 am. As you point out, it's possible a sophisticated attack could have also provided all kinds of distractions to prevent him from braking effectively.

I think the most likely explanation was that he was speeding and lost control, but feel free to disagree.

Re: Snowden distributed encrypted copies of NSA docs around ... by dsl on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @02:44AM (#5944527)
I was simply correcting your authoritative statement: However, steering and brakes are mechanical systems in Hastings' 2013 Mercedes C250 (like almost every other car)

You are dismissing it as unlikely, because you keep assuming that some subsystems would work as designed or intended.

I'm not comfortable discussing details on this point, but "just use the brakes" might not have been an option had the malicious payload been properly designed. I have maybe a basic to mid level of experience reverse engineering automotive firmware, and it would not be hard for me to pull off. God only knows what a state actor could come up with.

Re: Snowden distributed encrypted copies of NSA docs around ... by dredge on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @04:43AM (#5944827)
Can you recommend any automotive firmware reversing resources or published work?

Thanks.

Re: Snowden distributed encrypted copies of NSA docs around ... by dsl on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @07:03AM (#5945275)
This is a good intro and overview of security issues: http://embedded.communities.intel.com/community/en/applicati...

If you want to just hack around on CAN bus, check this project out: http://www.gadgetgangster.com/news/54/556

To get at actual firmware, you'll want to identify the ROM chips and wire up an appropriate reader. You might be able to get by with a bus pirate. Once you have the actual firmware, you should be able to identify the processor (get ready to learn old obscure Motorola instruction sets) and you're off to the races. If you luck out with an x86 or ARM processor I highly recommend the Hex Rays Decompiler.

I was working as a generalist on the team, so the HN expert collective may be able to give you better pointers on specific items.

Re: Snowden distributed encrypted copies of NSA docs around ... by gcb0 on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @12:26AM (#5944193)
> Electronics can activate the brakes, but can't cause the brakes to not activate because the pedal is connected hydraulically to the calipers

right, because ABS does not work by pulsating the pads off and back on...

What I would do if it was a spy movie:

    1. plant bomb underneath.
       maybe just a small (hard to find) fuse in the gas tank.
       make it activated by airbag sensors.
    2. hijack car electronics
    3. when target is inside, locks door.
       accelerate and mess with brakes
    4. he can turn as he wish. by the time he realizes what's going on,
       all he can do is try to avoid a high speed crash by then.
    5. with doors still locked, car crash and goes boom,
        just like they do in hollywood.
all the evidence left would be a burnt fuse in the exploded gas tank, and the firmware on the burnt electronics.
Re: Snowden distributed encrypted copies of NSA docs around ... by chaz on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @01:29AM (#5944361)
> right, because ABS does not work by pulsating the pads off and back on

So ABS can fully cut off brake pressure? My understanding is that it relieves extra pressure and that regardless of the valve position, either full force of the pedal (including locking the brakes) or reduced relieved pressure is still sufficient to stop a vehicle.

> What I would do if it was a spy movie

All posible. My comment was really just a response to Richard Clarke's comment that it could have been an "untraceable" "car cyberattack."

Re: Snowden distributed encrypted copies of NSA docs around ... by cschmidt on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @11:33PM (#5944024)
This Nova Science Now episode gives a demonstration where Prof. Yoshi Kohno of the University of Washington hacks a car and remotely slams on the breaks....

http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/nova/tech/can-science-stop-crime.htm...

Quite a nice segment.

Re: Snowden distributed encrypted copies of NSA docs around ... by VladRussian2 on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @12:46AM (#5944256)
>However, steering and brakes are mechanical systems in Hastings' 2013 Mercedes C250 (like almost every other car), and cannot be electronically overridden.

about ABS brakes (and thus absence of direct mechanical control by the driver) other people have already explained. The speed is controlled by electronic throttle control. Mercedes was among the first and brought drive-by-wire decade ago.

>The steering wheel is connected directly to the wheels, and can't be controlled by the electronics.

ever heard about electric assist steering? Mercedes does have it on the C250.

And btw, the modern cars don't explode. Poor Mercedes when guys like this will come into play http://www.usautoinjurylaw.com/types-of-accidents/explosions...

The reputation and perception is half the price of a Mercedes and this accident makes a dent in it (on the related topic - how much Toyota suffered for a runaway acceleration).

Re: Snowden distributed encrypted copies of NSA docs around ... by chaz on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @02:04AM (#5944437)
> ABS brakes

Correct me if I'm wrong: ABS doesn't cut off pressure to the brakes but instead relieves extra pressure. At no point can the ABS module ever fully cut off brake pressure that's being hydraulically applied by the driver. Incorrect?

> electronic throttle control

Yes, but my point was that regardless of what the throttle was doing, brakes can counter. If he was alert, he should have had reasonable time to start braking as the throttle opened up.

> ever heard about electric assist steering? Mercedes does have it on the C250.

Thanks -- this is a good catch.

> And btw, the modern cars don't explode

Agreed.

Re: Snowden distributed encrypted copies of NSA docs around ... by VladRussian2 on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @03:22AM (#5944620)
>Correct me if I'm wrong: ABS doesn't cut off pressure to the brakes but instead relieves extra pressure. At no point can the ABS module ever fully cut off brake pressure that's being hydraulically applied by the driver. Incorrect?

if relief valves are kept open (instead of open/close/open/close/... like during normal ABS operation) i don't think there will be any effective braking force.

Re: Snowden distributed encrypted copies of NSA docs around ... by quackerhacker on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @10:17PM (#5943735)
This is one of the reasons I can see Google Glass becoming more prevalent...security of one's well being through live streaming...even though I'm concerned about privacy, sometimes security through obscurity is not viable.
Re: Snowden distributed encrypted copies of NSA docs around ... by enupten on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @03:31AM (#5944646)
Yes give the regime more eyes, why don't you.
Re: Snowden distributed encrypted copies of NSA docs around ... by flyinRyan on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @09:21AM (#5945807)
It would work the same way police car cameras work now: if it caught the government breaking the law the footage would simply get lost somehow. If you stream it to some service, the PRISM group would see it and force the site to remove it.
Re: Snowden distributed encrypted copies of NSA docs around ... by kamjam on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @08:42PM (#5943414)
Woah. The scene of that accident looks straight out of a movie scene, looks too unreal to be a normal car accident!
Re: Snowden distributed encrypted copies of NSA docs around ... by thenewkid on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @09:16PM (#5943513)
Michael Hasting's friend was just interviewed on TV:

"His friends and family that know him, everyone says he drives like a grandma, so that right there doesn't seem like something he'd be doing, there's no way that he'd be acting erratic like that and driving out of control"

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZEIjna7672Q

Re: Snowden distributed encrypted copies of NSA docs around ... by codex on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @10:07PM (#5943692)
Do people who drive like grandmas spend bread on a 200 hp Mercedes coupe?

According to this article [1], Hastings describes himself as a "a recovering drunk/addict/screw-up." In another True/Slant piece, he says, "I have smoked crack." He crashed a car in a drunk-driving accident at 19.

It's funny how geeks, who pride themselves on rationality, throw Occam's Razor out the window at the drop of a hat.

[1] http://www.breitbart.com/Big-Journalism/2013/06/21/LA-Weekly...

Re: Snowden distributed encrypted copies of NSA docs around ... by MRSallee on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @10:47PM (#5943845)
FWIW, 200 HP is not a lot and is, as far as I can tell, Mercedes' least powerful engine (201 HP 4-cylinder). In a 3,500 lb. car, it will not be especially fast.

(I used to have a 3,500 lb. coupe, a Pontiac GTO. Now that was fast. It had a 400 HP V8.)

Re: Snowden distributed encrypted copies of NSA docs around ... by fnordfnordfnord on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @10:35PM (#5943816)
>Do people who drive like grandmas spend bread on a 200 hp Mercedes coupe?

I know a guy with at least a dozen cars, including a McLaren F1, drives way more cautiously than most grandmothers I know.

Re: Snowden distributed encrypted copies of NSA docs around ... by ccera on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @11:54PM (#5944096)
In point of fact, my grandma drives a Mercedes coupe. So the answer to your question is yes.
Re: Snowden distributed encrypted copies of NSA docs around ... by flyinRyan on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @10:01AM (#5946050)
Yes, it's a common frustration in the US that when you see a 911, Ferrari, Dodge Viper or whatever it's usually being driven slightly below the speed limit by some (presumably rich) old man.

And P.S. Occam's Razor is just a guide line. Many things happen every day that violate it. The US government has murdered people before and tried to cover it up, so it's not beyond the realm of believably or possibility.

Re: Snowden distributed encrypted copies of NSA docs around ... by danbruc on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @09:30PM (#5943560)
There seems to be some evidence directly contradicting this statement.
Re: Snowden distributed encrypted copies of NSA docs around ... by obstacle1 on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @09:40PM (#5943594)
People are speculating that the controls in his car may have been compromised. [e.g. [1]]

I'm not saying this is true; just that it is what people are speculating. Frankly I don't know whether or not it's possible to remotely take over that particular car's steering/acceleration mechanisms.

[1] - http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/06/24/michael-hastings-ca...

Re: Snowden distributed encrypted copies of NSA docs around ... by jlgreco on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @08:46PM (#5943431)
Sigh.

No, that car hit that tree. It wasn't dropped off by a flatbed truck or something. And yes, cars can catch fire during high-speed collisions.

Not to toot my own horn, but... https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5936521

Re: Snowden distributed encrypted copies of NSA docs around ... by VladRussian2 on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @09:15PM (#5943511)
who said that NSA is limiting themselves only to reading your emails.

"Bush advisor: Hastings crash ‘consistent with a car cyberattack’"

http://rt.com/usa/michael-hastings-cyber-car-218/

Re: Snowden distributed encrypted copies of NSA docs around ... by redthrowaway on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @09:38PM (#5943588)
I remember, years ago when I was working for BMW, reports that security researchers had been able to gain control over a vehicle by compromising the wifi that the Tire Pressure Sensors used to communicate with the central onboard computer. If a few security researchers could develop that capability, I'd be stunned if intelligence organizations weren't doing the same.
Re: Snowden distributed encrypted copies of NSA docs around ... by X-Istence on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @09:58PM (#5943657)
Please don't use Wifi. Wifi doesn't refer to all radio communications, Wifi specifically refers to IEEE standard 802.11.

The TPMS systems do not use Wifi, nor do they generally transmit in the 2.4 GHz band. The system from the paper you mention sits at 315 MHz.

The paper is available here: http://www.winlab.rutgers.edu/~Gruteser/papers/xu_tpms10.pdf

Re: Snowden distributed encrypted copies of NSA docs around ... by redthrowaway on Friday June 28, 2013 @08:05PM (#5960986)
It's not an important distinction, but I still appreciate the clarification.
Re: Snowden distributed encrypted copies of NSA docs around ... by commandar on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @10:37PM (#5943818)
Describing Richard Clarke as a "Bush advisor" is a case of technically true, but sort of an unusual label for the man and somewhat misleading in the impression it might give of who he is.

His counter-terror position was a holdover from the Clinton administration, and he eventually left the Bush administration on very bitter terms; I've seen the term "character assassination" used to describe the way he was treated by the administration on numerous ocassions.

Re: Snowden distributed encrypted copies of NSA docs around ... by jlgreco on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @09:27PM (#5943552)
I am not denying the possibility that there was fowl play. I am denying that "the wreck looks like something from a movie" is evidence of anything at all. Keen difference there.
Re: Snowden distributed encrypted copies of NSA docs around ... by antoko on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @09:58PM (#5943655)
I am not denying the possibility that there was fowl play.

So you think chicken sabotage is a possibility then?

Re: Snowden distributed encrypted copies of NSA docs around ... by jlgreco on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @10:05PM (#5943681)
Ha! In fact, I find it rather likely that birds were involved.
Re: Snowden distributed encrypted copies of NSA docs around ... by achughes on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @10:03PM (#5943675)
You do realize that RT is a directly funded by the Russian Government don't you? There is a great incentive for them to paint the US in a bad light.
Re: Snowden distributed encrypted copies of NSA docs around ... by fnordfnordfnord on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @10:51PM (#5943857)
That doesn't make it all false. The best propaganda is also true.
Re: Snowden distributed encrypted copies of NSA docs around ... by achughes on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @11:34PM (#5944028)
But it also doesn't make it true
Re: Snowden distributed encrypted copies of NSA docs around ... by fnordfnordfnord on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @08:06AM (#5945447)
That property exists for all news media.
Re: Snowden distributed encrypted copies of NSA docs around ... by jlgreco on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @10:07PM (#5943688)
Re: Snowden distributed encrypted copies of NSA docs around ... by achughes on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @11:44PM (#5944063)
I'm not trying to say that its impossible, not by any means, but the RT article presents the statement as something that is assumed to be true, whereas the HuffPo article presents it among a large list of conspiracy theories. The RT article is clearly written to act a propaganda, and the article from the post gives a more objective view, where there is a slim possibility that the car was hacked, but it is just as unlikely as any other.
Re: Snowden distributed encrypted copies of NSA docs around ... by VladRussian2 on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @12:13AM (#5944146)
sorry, man, just grabbed a link about Clarke.