Re:Is Wine Bullshit?
by iandanforth on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @05:47PM
(#5942673)
Done this. Totally false. A merlot in a cab bottle tastes like a cab and everyone who likes cab says how much they like that wine.
False? People liking cabernet sauvignon does not imply that they cannot like a merlot in a cabernet sauvignon bottle.
Our experiences are different. You seem caught up with categorization.
I'm fairly confident I couldn't tell a merlot from a cabernet, blind, from a glass. But that doesn't mean one wine doesn't taste nicer than another, or goes better with a particular dish. And that's what I was alluding to.
I mean, it is subjective in the same sense that the sky being blue is a subjective thing. In other words, a philosophical debate over qualia.
But if you ever had a wine-tasting dinner with a large company of people, with a ranked progression of wines, you would not doubt that certain qualities of wine are absolutely shared amongst almost everyone who drinks them.