News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Basic income as an answer to all out automation by chii on Monday June 24, 2013 @07:38AM (#5932249)
While i understand your argument (and i wish the world really worked that way too), the problem with determining "vote" by money is that not everyone started off with equal vote in the beginning. Some people got rich thru schemes that was only available to them, and thru either luck, force of coercion, or trickery/deceit. Thus, the honest poor will remain poor, and any influence their vote has will be crowded out by the ill gotten gains by the dishonest ones. Which is what we have today, ala lobby money, political campaign money, transnational corporations which pay way less tax than they "should" be, yet enjoy the same rights as a tax paying citizen (e.g., property rights protection).
Re:Basic income as an answer to all out automation by michas on Monday June 24, 2013 @08:21AM (#5932406)
When I was talking about "voting with money" i didn't mean any political vote. I just meant that if you are in capitalist market and all services are provided by private companies then you have power over that companies because you can decide not to buy their products or services. That's something that gives you a freedom of choice. Lobby money, political campaign money and other things you mentioned can only matter if government rules most of fields in our lives. If you limit goverment's powers to minimum then bribing politicians has just no incentive to a person giving a bribe.
Re:Basic income as an answer to all out automation by chii on Monday June 24, 2013 @10:34AM (#5933161)
Things that tend to have a natural monopoly (for example, water pipes) don't work very well in a truly capitalistic market where everything is privatized. Unless you start with everyone being on equal footing, the incumbents can employ a strategy where they force new entrants to the market to pay exponentially more and thus snuff them out before they become a threat, and therefore can set their price to whatever the market will beare. Imagine you have to spend the majority of your income on potable water, simply because you can't get it anywhere else! You will pay it, because its your life, and it has infinite value if you can't get enough of it. Therefore, whoever controls the water can control others thru this power.