News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Basic income as an answer to all out automation by scarmig on Monday June 24, 2013 @04:16AM (#5931643)
If somebody wants to work, shouldn't we make it possible for them?

The point of a basic income is that it allows people to work. Because it's unconditional (at least in the variant I support), there are no marginal disincentive effects.

If you want to call having people dig holes and fill them back in "work," okay, fine. But at that point I don't see why we shouldn't just call simply living a job and call it a day, because at least that way people can focus on valuable economic tasks that a government can't necessarily see or effectively plan.

And it's harder to attack because it is universal and unconditional. Compare foodstamps and Medicaid to a program that's available to all income classes, such as, say, Medicare or Social Security. One class is constantly attacked, while attacking the other ends political careers.

Re:Basic income as an answer to all out automation by yummyfajitas on Monday June 24, 2013 @07:09AM (#5932140)
Because it's unconditional (at least in the variant I support), there are no marginal disincentive effects.

If you believe in diminishing marginal utility, there certainly are.

Compare foodstamps and Medicaid to a program that's available to all income classes, such as, say, Medicare or Social Security.

These programs are not universal - no one under 65 receives them. Those programs are popular because the beneficiaries of redistribution vote for them at high rates, while the people being redistributed from vote at lower rates.

It's nothing but a standard "pay some people to vote for us" scheme.

Re:Basic income as an answer to all out automation by ZeroGravitas on Monday June 24, 2013 @09:40AM (#5932763)
Isn't the point that many unemployment benefits actually penalize people for taking a job? i.e. it's the difference between the marginal utility falling towards 0 as you earn/receive more money and the the utility being below 0 as you are punished for working by having welfare equal to more than you have earned taken away.
Re:Basic income as an answer to all out automation by yummyfajitas on Monday June 24, 2013 @10:06AM (#5932930)
It's not actually that bad. Your consumption is basically flat as you go from $0k/year to $20k/year earned income.

http://www.chrisstucchio.com/blog/2011/why_the_poor_dont_wor...

Re:Basic income as an answer to all out automation by ZeroGravitas on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @05:41AM (#5938377)
I don't have a strong disagreement with his overall point, but think there's some strange data leading to those values. The families (average 1.7 people) earning less than $5,000 per year, seem to better educated, "whiter" and have more cars and homes than you might expect when compared with other earning levels.

One possibility is that these data are skewed by small business owners that made a loss that year. Together those who earn less than 5K actually have an average income of -2,500 and list average self-employment income at -8,000 dollars.

Re:Basic income as an answer to all out automation by yummyfajitas on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @06:54AM (#5938580)
Interesting. If true, this would skew the numbers I cite and basically every other poverty number out there.
Re:Basic income as an answer to all out automation by nhaehnle on Monday June 24, 2013 @06:16PM (#5936109)
> If you want to call having people dig holes and fill them back in "work," okay, fine.

Well, it is work, but it's not what I want people to do. Why on earth would you assume that that is what I want?

Whatever happened to giving the benefit of the doubt, and perhaps showing some curiosity as to what the other person really intends?

I have explained that a bit in response to another comment here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5936103