News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:For secretive surveillance court, rare scrutiny in wake o... by rayiner on Monday June 24, 2013 @01:53AM (#5931257)
You can't take WaPo articles on law at face value just as you'd never take a WaPo article on some scientific discovery at face value. The author seems confused about the nature of precedent here...

Courts interpret the Constitution as a matter of course, and so do federal agencies. They have to, for the simple reason that the Constitution does not allow federal courts to issue advisory opinions. An agency cannot ask a court: "is this Constitutional?" Similarly, a lower court cannot ask an appellate court: "is this Constitutional?" If a Constitutional question arises in the course of deciding a case, even a low level adjudicatory body (say, the Social Security Administration) is empowered to render an opinion on Constitutionality. That opinion might be binding precedent within that adjudicatory body, but, and this is the key, it's not precedent anywhere else. The federal government cannot cite the FISA courts 4th amendment interpretation as binding precedent in a federal district court case.

I'm very wary of secret courts and secret opinions. I think the public nature of dockets and opinions is one of the great virtues of the Anglo-American legal system. I don't think it's a good thing for the FISC court to keep these opinions secret. However, I think it's important to understand what is actually going on, not just some journalist's color on what is going on, so we can be worried about the right things and not the wrong things.

There is something to be worried about, and it's part of a larger problem. Congress has been increasingly chipping away at the scope of the federal judiciary. Citing overburdened federal courts (which are overburdened because Congress refuses to fill vacancies in a timely manner or to increase the number of judgeships to keep up with the amount of litigation), it creates alternative bodies to handle different kinds of disputes. Sometimes that's a fine thing (not every Social Security claim needs to go directly to federal district court), but it's also a worrying trend. By the way, it's totally Constitutional: Congress is explicitly empowered to set the jurisdiction of the lower (below the Supreme Court) federal courts as it sees fit. Indeed, it could abolish them entirely.

There are no comments on this comment yet.