Re:Obama’s crackdown views leaks as aiding enemies of U.S.
by dllthomas on Monday June 24, 2013 @01:04AM
(#5931105)
Judicial review is not an enumerated power, but "created out of whole cloth" is misleading. It had precedent in Common Law, and purportedly it was discussed as a possibility before actually being used in Marbury (at which point the country had only been around ~12 years).
Re:Obama’s crackdown views leaks as aiding enemies of U.S.
by dragonwriter on Monday June 24, 2013 @01:20AM
(#5931159)
> Judicial review is not an enumerated power
Its not a separately enumerated power, but you can't resolve a legal case without first determining what the law is, including resolving conflicts between different laws that appear to be applicable, such as the Constitution and federal statutes.
Re:Obama’s crackdown views leaks as aiding enemies of U.S.
by dllthomas on Monday June 24, 2013 @01:40AM
(#5931228)
Not unreasonable.
Re:Obama’s crackdown views leaks as aiding enemies of U.S.
by dllthomas on Monday June 24, 2013 @10:34AM
(#5933160)
Further, setting a precedent of resolving conflict between laws by saying "These conflict and the constitution trumps statute" is overturning a law as unconstitutional.
Re:Obama’s crackdown views leaks as aiding enemies of U.S.
by dnautics on Monday June 24, 2013 @11:18AM
(#5933458)
how could it have precedent in common law? The UK has no such thing as a written constitution to be interpreted in quite the same fashion.
Re:Obama’s crackdown views leaks as aiding enemies of U.S.
by dllthomas on Monday June 24, 2013 @01:00PM
(#5934177)
I'd read something about it, but am not finding my sources, so I'll drop the claim for now.
However, it does seem to follow inherently from:
1) Precedent (as policy, not any particular instance)
2) The ability to determine/resolve contradictions between laws
3) The supremacy clause of the Constitution
If the court finds (per 2) that a given law is in contradiction with the Constitution, they must resolve the issue by deferring to the Constitution (per 3). Later courts must find the same (per 1). Therefor, you have a law which is effectively overturned by being deemed in conflict with the Constitution.
(Not that I'm complaining, I'm fine with the court doing this, but it would be nice if it were an enumerated power)