News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Demonstrations to protest NSA spying planned for July 4th by tptacek on Saturday June 22, 2013 @04:33PM (#5925061)
(1) Is never going to happen. Even civil cases in the US can be conducted under seal, and those very rarely pertain to national security. This is exactly what the parent commenter was referring to when he said that people should figure out exactly what their demand is; the demand in item (1) here is totally unrealistic.

(2) and (3) seem very straightforward, realistic, and productive.

Re:Demonstrations to protest NSA spying planned for July 4th by scythe on Saturday June 22, 2013 @05:12PM (#5925163)
(1) should be broken among its parts. The state secrets privilege is hard to get rid of, but it is realistic to call for the repeal of the "library records provision":

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Library_records_provision#Secti...

Notably, Google itself has launched a campaign against the gag order related to NSLs, which we should all (hopefully) support!

Re:Demonstrations to protest NSA spying planned for July 4th by ScottBurson on Saturday June 22, 2013 @09:29PM (#5925895)
I think the keyword in (1) is "blanket". I'm not sure exactly what the intended definition is, and this should be clarified, but I'd guess the intent includes surveillance without specific probable cause.

If I'm right, then I think this might be achievable. It would not say that any surveillance could be challenged in a public proceeding, only indiscriminate surveillance. Production of a lawful court order would presumably be sufficient to inactivate this provision. Hmm, I suppose things could get sticky if there were debate over the lawfulness of the court order... nonetheless, I'm not prepared to give up on this yet.