That's a terrible justification for not protesting. Free societies require courage.
+1
As for being courageous in a free society: Let me know when you find one. we can both move there and be courageous together. In the interim, I'm going to play by the rules of the game, as I'm stuck in the system.
Perhaps you guys don't understand this: they have _really_ big guns. waaaay bigger than anything we have. and they have the authority to use them when they're threatened by acts of mass protest. the Executive's powers used at Kent State ages ago have only gotten stronger. Don't be like those poor bastards. or the Seattle WTO protesters. or the DNC/RNC protesters.
Seriously, they _want_ you to sue them. Just do it.
Thanks for the downvotes. perhaps you could combine them with a reply of why I'm wrong in my reasoning?
The ethos of Hacker News is all about changing the status quo, and America as a country was about asserting independence and changing the status quo, in the name of certain kinds of rights that wound up embodied in the Constitution.
Arguing that protests are useless, that we don't live in a free society, that courage is unnecessary: it's frankly quite sad. People died in previous wars to give us the right to protest, the freedom in our society, and it is necessary that people should continue to fight to keep things that way, with courage.
Your reasoning sounds a little paranoid, like the "government has already won" and that there's nothing we can do about it. That's not going to be a popular attitude.
Perhaps you believe you live in a free society, I don't. I understand the ramifications of the Fourteenth Amendment, and how the bill of rights was filtered through the 14th to see what still applied to "subjects of congress" (hint: only the 2nd amendment comes out unscathed due to DC v Heller). I've read (and used) the Canadian Ownership and Control Determination Act [1], and understand how it allows someone to actually own people (actual slavery). I've filed UCC-1 Liens against people and had sheriffs seize debtor's property or put people in jail for not paying (debt slavery). These are not signs of a free society. these are signs of fascism and tyranny.
I hope you'll forgive my worldview for being different than yours, but perhaps we can find some common ground: We both want to live in a free society. We both want a populace to show courage. we think it's quite sad that people died in previous wars to give us the right to protest. We both think the government has already won (the people are the government), and there's nothing we can do about that. We both think is necessary that people should continue to fight to keep things that way, with courage.
I bet we agree on many more things, actually.
Demonstrations can and will be used to crack down further. Despite our rights to protest, government will still use them as a way to frighten the non demonstrators. This is what we have seen in the UK. Protesters are re-defined as criminals as and when it suits.
Also, I think you probably have a point in suggesting the use of the law. Seems to me as an outsider that a lot of US progression has been via enlightened judges.......eventually. My suggestion would be to raise huge amounts of cash to fight in the courts and lobby hard.
I really do hate to say this, because it yet again shows up the political disconnect we all seem to have, but governments simply ignore protest. Well, unless its Middle East style, with huge amounts of violence and political types dragged out and, well, killed. And, that isnt going to happen in the West, right? Look, we in the UK had 1 million people march in London against Gulf War 2. That is like 5 million marching in DC (roughly, if I have my maths right). And guess what.... the UK government ignored them flat. Later, the UK people voted that government back in to power. Total waste of time.
When was the last time protest really worked? More over, should it?
The only remedy we have in this country is lawsuits. Not class-actions, either; individual lawsuits for $500k each, for egregiously prejudicing your individual rights guaranteed by the constitution. ten thousand or so of those, with the president's name in all caps (head of the Unitary Executive) listed as the defendant.
or, you know, you could try to make a well-regulated militia of 3D-printed pea shooters, so you can overthrow the largest and most heavily-armed military in the history of the world. that'll definitely work.
Myself, I appreciate the disclosure I'm being given that Scott McNealy was right all those years ago when he said we have zero privacy anyway. The government has the right to do whatever they want with their property. if you use/are their property (isn't that ARPAnet thing US military property?), expect them to enforce their interest in that property.
TL;DR for the downvoters (+6 to -2 in less than 20 minutes? hilarious): PROTEST BAD. LAWSUITS GOOD.