Re:No One Is Innocent
by baddox on Saturday June 22, 2013 @12:32AM
(#5922601)
> We've chosen a democratic process, which means that we've chosen in aggregate to be governed by whoever shows up.
I'm curious how you justify this claim. In what meaningful way has anyone chosen a democratic process? I certainly never chose it, and I've never been asked if I approve. I am occasionally given the "opportunity" to vote for one of a few candidates for various political offices, and there are sometimes even referenda, but I have no choice in the fact that this is how our government operates. If this were a dictatorship (as in, a single ruler has all government authority), would you also say that "we've chosen a dictatorship"?
You say that the democratic process is horrifying, and I agree, but I disagree that the people being governed have any role in choosing to be governed by this style of government even if we make the contentious assumption that they actually have a voice in the specific decisions the government makes. The "democratic government" that rules us (here, I'm referring specifically to the United States, but I suspect it holds for all Western democracies) maintains its power through systematic and unapologetic violence against anyone who challenges it, just like any other type of government. Of course, that last sentence is somewhat unnecessary, because that's built into the definition of "government."
I also completely disagree with your claim that flawed governments (and indeed governments at all) are a necessary cost of civilization, but that's a longer story that I may type when I have something other than an iPad. Suffice it to say that I agree that we should try to fix it, but I'm convinced that the only way to do so is from the outside. Because governments are by definition organizations which claim to be the sole legitimate purveyors of violence in a region, and claim to be self-policing, I do not believe it makes any sense to attempt to use the political process itself to change or fix them from the inside.
I'm curious how you justify this claim. In what meaningful way has anyone chosen a democratic process? I certainly never chose it, and I've never been asked if I approve. I am occasionally given the "opportunity" to vote for one of a few candidates for various political offices, and there are sometimes even referenda, but I have no choice in the fact that this is how our government operates. If this were a dictatorship (as in, a single ruler has all government authority), would you also say that "we've chosen a dictatorship"?
You say that the democratic process is horrifying, and I agree, but I disagree that the people being governed have any role in choosing to be governed by this style of government even if we make the contentious assumption that they actually have a voice in the specific decisions the government makes. The "democratic government" that rules us (here, I'm referring specifically to the United States, but I suspect it holds for all Western democracies) maintains its power through systematic and unapologetic violence against anyone who challenges it, just like any other type of government. Of course, that last sentence is somewhat unnecessary, because that's built into the definition of "government."
I also completely disagree with your claim that flawed governments (and indeed governments at all) are a necessary cost of civilization, but that's a longer story that I may type when I have something other than an iPad. Suffice it to say that I agree that we should try to fix it, but I'm convinced that the only way to do so is from the outside. Because governments are by definition organizations which claim to be the sole legitimate purveyors of violence in a region, and claim to be self-policing, I do not believe it makes any sense to attempt to use the political process itself to change or fix them from the inside.