Re:Why the 5 Star Rating System Isn't Suited to Local Reviews
by pmjoyce on Monday May 04, 2009 @05:12AM
(#592141)
I still think this lacks any degree of real clarity, although I admit that it looks like it does. At best I might use the trend graphs as an starting point from which to interrogate the qualitative data (comments).
One major problem is the need to click through to the detail page to see these charts, this doesn't lend itself to easy decision making on the fly. However, the real issue is that even when you do click through, it doesn't show probably another important metric by which to judge: volume of votes over time. If you were to add that into the equation and suddenly the user has 3 charts per venue to interrogate to establish the reliability of the initial score out of 5.
I think that's a reasonably big ask for someone who just wants to know where's to get a decent Kung Pao chicken around here.
Re:Why the 5 Star Rating System Isn't Suited to Local Reviews
by nimbix on Sunday May 03, 2009 @11:17PM
(#591850)
The article made me think that they use a one-dimensional star count (could be because of that image), so my reply was formed around that idea. I have to admit I never checked what kind of rating Yelp actually uses.
Here's a screenshot:
http://img.skitch.com/20090504-n2jsr44y1py38pbd5wgcqs5uyn.pn...