Re:The SIMON and SPECK Families of Lightweight Block Ciphers
by tptacek on Friday June 21, 2013 @12:35PM
(#5919089)
Yeah, I wasn't thinking straight about that either. :)
I think the Xbox TEA hash is another example of a lightweight cipher having problems when used as a hash construction.
Certainly I wouldn't ever advise someone to use SIMON or SPECK in production.
Also, I'll channel your for a moment: don't build your own crypto! And don't use lightweight block ciphers for data you care about: many are designed to skirt the edges of "too weak", their implementations haven't been side-channel-attacked quite as often as OpenSSL's AES, and they haven't been reviewed to anything like the extent that AES has been and/or have been found wanting (TEA). Yes, experts can put them to good use, but be very careful and don't use them before ruling out the conservative AES-HMAC-SHA2 as well as more modern constructions like Keccak in AEAD mode.