Re:Why the 5 Star Rating System Isn't Suited to Local Reviews
by derefr on Sunday May 03, 2009 @08:33PM
(#591638)
There's nothing wrong with asking users to rate things out of five. However, just seeing an out-of-five score is, indeed, pointless when you talk about products that can vary per-person and over time.
I'd suggest that the score be rendered as a Sparkline of aggregate-score-over-time, with a surrounding colored field, the width of which is the deviation for that aggregate sample point. Thus, you could see whether a five-star restaurant used to be a three-star at a glance, and see how many people disagree with the current rating with a simple visual geometric comparison.
I'd suggest that the score be rendered as a Sparkline of aggregate-score-over-time, with a surrounding colored field, the width of which is the deviation for that aggregate sample point. Thus, you could see whether a five-star restaurant used to be a three-star at a glance, and see how many people disagree with the current rating with a simple visual geometric comparison.