That doesn't mean it's a good situation, but existential threat is greatly overstating the problem. People would have to have an extra baby, MAYBE.
Also, notice I intentionally said an existential threat to society, not humanity. It's fair to say that no longer being able to perform surgical procedures safely would be very destabilizing to modern society.
Our bodys' immune systems have been around for a while. If bacteria haven't become resistant to them by now, I don't see any immediate threat.
Forget about promiscuity vs. insularity- modern society is not built on the backs of twenty-year-olds. If humans suddenly did not survive much past their prime reproductive age, humanity would survive with absolute ease, but modern society would undergo dramatic change.
Sure you'd see average life expectancy drop dramatically, but I don't think you'd see humans die out as a species.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mathematical_modelling_of_infec...
I wonder about that. I'll bet the drop would be pretty small if we started the aggressive public health measures they took before antibiotics.
With no antibiotics, the bacteria would spread more rapidly, and more people would be sick, and die, right?
>presents an existential threat to modern society
What responders seem to be responding to:
>presents an existential threat to humanity
The latter one is obviously wrong. The former, I think it's more likely than not that it's wrong. Sure, globalization would make bacterial outbreaks more likely but simple things like more frequent hand washing and wearing surgical masks any time you're out in public would cut the infection rate down tremendously.
There are many societal things we could do to improve society's chances of survival before antibiotic resistance would become an existential threat to society.
It's possible that there would be large societal changes if the ability to undergo surgery or work in risky professions is hampered by an increased risk of lethal infections.
Vancomycin used to be a big gun, but not really any longer. Source: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vancomycin
From the article:
For many years since its initial use, vancomycin has traditionally been reserved as a drug of "last resort"... Recently, however, vancomycin resistant organisms are becoming common. Thus, vancomycin is increasingly being displaced from this role by newer antibiotics
>So governments limit Vancomycin use so as to not give bacteria the opportunity to evolve and develop resistance.
Vancomycin actually has a high hurdle to use naturally. It possesses poor oral bioavailability; it must be given intravenously for most infections. It can't be abused as easily by doctors prescribing it for things like colds because you have to be hooked up to an IV to get it.
Having said that, it is still a very old antibiotic (from 1953) and resistance has built up from its use. A few months ago I had Vancomycin + Ciprofloxacin administered intravenously for four days due to an infection following a severe puncture wound to my foot. It's still prescribed but it's not "the big guns" it used to be.
The only solution is to get the medical profession to stop shotgunning antibiotics at every problem.
If it gets bad enough, outpatient antibiotics use will be a thing of the past. Need antibiotics? You're staying in a facility where someone will monitor you and make sure you take the full course and don't make our resistance problems worse. It won't necessarily be a hospital and you won't necessarily be watched by doctors or nurses, but compliance will be mandatory and enforced. Society has ways of defending itself.
I hope it doesn't get that bad, but needs must, when the Devil calls the tune.
Right now the most common antibiotics we have (eg penicillin + synthetic derivatives) use a B-lactam ring to disrupt cell wall production. Now we start to see bacteria that are resistant to this attack, eg MRSA (Methicillin-resistant staphylococcus aureus), that in worst-case scenarios make even simple surgical procedures life-threatening.
Then we bring in the big guns, things like Vancomycin that disrupt cell wall production using different methods. But then we start to see Vancomycin-resistant microorganisms. So governments limit Vancomycin use so as to not give bacteria the opportunity to evolve and develop resistance. Thus drug manufacturers are unwilling to research new antibiotics because they can't make a profit off of restricted-access antibiotics.
So it's largely a game of cat and mouse that could very well result in a deadly worldwide epidemic. New ways of looking at the problem such as the one described in the article could, without even being hyperbolic, save billions of lives.