Re:Do we need a Human Data Project?
by SteveArmstrong on Thursday June 20, 2013 @01:09PM
(#5913225)
With the way the article compared it to donating organs, I figured this was a system for releasing information after death. In that case, the de-anonymizing problem is less of an issue. (Informed consent of this problem would still be needed of course)
That makes sense. I guess the system would have to be very much about informed consent or filter through data that makes it too easy to trace down to individuals?
Nice ARS link.
Just to close the loop on this thread, this summary by Zack Kohane is pretty spot on: http://commonhealth.wbur.org/2013/06/more-surveillance-healt...
Most people don't realize how easy it is to use scraps of public info to identify people in data sets (the canonical example is here: http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2009/09/your-secrets-live...).
For research to be bioethically sound, people have to be able to give informed consent. Most people are ill equipped to get their heads around these ideas enough to actually be informed. I see this all the time with DNA data. Even exceptionally bright researchers can delude themselves into thinking that DNA sequence data isn't identifiable because you'd "need some other DNA linked to the person to identify them". As if that's going to be a problem in another few years.
I agree in principle it would be great to have vast troves of data to mine. I'm just not sure how to square that with existing laws and regulations.