News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple's New Mac Pro Begins Showing Up in Benchmarks by tracker1 on Thursday June 20, 2013 @01:40AM (#5910389)
Don't be too sure of that.. plenty of pros want upgradable systems... Most of the mac pro users I know tend to keep them 4-5 years or more, with an upgrade cycle every 12-24 months (faster cpu, more ram, ssd, etc) in the same box. The new form factor really limits that, and would probably be better served with a consumer grade CPU etc.. this is much closer to a mid-range desktop a lot of people have been asking for, except it's going to cost an arm and a leg.
Re:Apple's New Mac Pro Begins Showing Up in Benchmarks by colmvp on Thursday June 20, 2013 @02:10AM (#5910468)
Yeah, as much as I love the aesthetics, I'm predicting poor sales unless the price is comparable to other desktops. It's precisely the reason I avoided the Cube back in 2000/2001 and opted for the Tower.
Re:Apple's New Mac Pro Begins Showing Up in Benchmarks by Shivetya on Thursday June 20, 2013 @08:12AM (#5911543)
Comparable to whose desktops? The server edition of the Mac Mini is a thousand dollars and its absolutely nothing special in hardware. I haven't seen this much disappointment amongst people who actually use the hardware when it comes to an Apple product ever. Well, we have the cheer leaders for the new hardware but its pretty obvious they don't use the current hardware. You get these types in any conversation.

No internal expansion, no built in CD/DVD drives, limited memory, no apparent means of upgrading the video, and if one of the components breaks its off to the store. Yet if predictions are right this will be even more expensive than current solutions. Worse, Thunderbolt enclosures are not cheap, if can even find them.

Unless those price predictions are way off base I and a few others I know have even started serious talk of going hackintosh.

Apple had every opportunity to produce a slimmer tower that still gave options for expansion. Instead its a replay of the "Cube" days.

Its not even good looking, the Cube at least could pass as a conversation piece

Re:Apple's New Mac Pro Begins Showing Up in Benchmarks by tracker1 on Thursday June 20, 2013 @04:27PM (#5914723)
I think it's pretty good looking myself... just that it would be better with desktop class parts, and sold as a mid-range option (between the mini and pro). As it stands, as a new pro, I think it's a failure. I'm with you on the hackintosh route.
Re:Apple's New Mac Pro Begins Showing Up in Benchmarks by sliverstorm on Thursday June 20, 2013 @03:28AM (#5910705)
this is much closer to a mid-range desktop a lot of people have been asking for, except it's going to cost an arm and a leg.

Kind of like Apple is pulling something like this:

Mid-range desktop you say? Hmm... Yes, I've got just the thing- How about a mid-range desktop with the price of a top-end desktop?

Re:Apple's New Mac Pro Begins Showing Up in Benchmarks by ricardobeat on Thursday June 20, 2013 @03:48AM (#5910775)
I don't see how a machine that has almost 1GB/s disk transfer speeds, 60GB/s memory bandwidth and 7 teraflops GPU power (almost double the top of the line geforce) is "mid-range" unless you're from the future.
Re:Apple's New Mac Pro Begins Showing Up in Benchmarks by mahyarm on Thursday June 20, 2013 @04:09AM (#5910842)
If you do something that is fairly CPU bound, such as large project C++ compiles for iOS software, it matters, a lot.

GPUs are not going to make those compiles any faster, and apple has abandoned distcc. The more CPU cores the better.

I'm seriously disappointed that they are not offering a 2 or even 3 socket version of the new mac pro. They're all, fuck you iOS developers, the only people who are practically stuck on our platform.

Re:Apple's New Mac Pro Begins Showing Up in Benchmarks by diroussel on Thursday June 20, 2013 @07:44AM (#5911464)
I don't think slow C++ compilation was the problem that Apple thought it was addressing in the new MacPro.
Re:Apple's New Mac Pro Begins Showing Up in Benchmarks by dasmoth on Thursday June 20, 2013 @04:11AM (#5910851)
I don't think performance numbers have been a good way to distinguish between mid-range and high-end for a while now. Especially for users who are looking for a single machine that covers a range of uses including games.

ECC memory is a high-end feature. As is the specific choice of GPUs. Arguably, the fast PCIe SSD counts, too, although I suspect that won't last -- everyone benefits from I/O bandwidth, and there's no particular reason, other than market segmentation, for PCIe SSDs to be more expensive.

Re:Apple's New Mac Pro Begins Showing Up in Benchmarks by ricardobeat on Thursday June 20, 2013 @04:39AM (#5910921)
So what makes the Mac Pro a mid-range computer? Bear in mind that it's not a consumer product, it's squarely aimed at audio/video/graphics professionals, even though it'll blow any current gaming rig out of the water with those specs.
Re:Apple's New Mac Pro Begins Showing Up in Benchmarks by kryten on Thursday June 20, 2013 @07:42AM (#5911457)
It is a mid-range machine and it is a consumer product.

It's more a Mac Mini Pro than a Mac Pro.

This is a high end machine. Go compare:

http://www.hp.com/united-states/campaigns/workstations/z820_...

Re:Apple's New Mac Pro Begins Showing Up in Benchmarks by ricardobeat on Friday June 21, 2013 @02:11AM (#5916814)
They're in the exact same ballpark. That workstation has 2 x 8 cores, and a higher RAM ceiling on it's favor. On the other hand, it's limited to 7 PCI slots for expansion, three of them slow/legacy, vs a max of 36 chained devices on the Pro. The quadro GPU it comes with is 3.5x less powerful than the one in the mac pro, and it will come in at a higher price tag.

Do you by any chance drive a mid-range Bentley?

Re:Apple's New Mac Pro Begins Showing Up in Benchmarks by kryten on Friday June 21, 2013 @02:40PM (#5920090)
Except in the HP it all goes inside, which is where I need it so it can be locked and powered from one supply, every part is replaceable, the GPU can be upgraded, it has a hot swap enclosure built in and guaranteed support for 5 years.

Plus some kit I use won't go on the end of a thunderbolt bus...

Re:Apple's New Mac Pro Begins Showing Up in Benchmarks by ricardobeat on Sunday June 23, 2013 @08:57PM (#5930319)
The Thunderbolt bus is faster than 4 out of the 7 PCIe ports on the HP. You're trying hard not to get it.
Re:Apple's New Mac Pro Begins Showing Up in Benchmarks by tracker1 on Thursday June 20, 2013 @04:33PM (#5914765)
Well, being limited to a 256gb mSATA SSD might hold it back a little. It's not the hardware I have issue with so much as the form factor... I think the form factor screams low-mid range, and not upgradable. I think the form factor would be great with mid-range consumer hardware, a Core i7 and two consumer class GPUs.
Re:Apple's New Mac Pro Begins Showing Up in Benchmarks by ricardobeat on Friday June 21, 2013 @01:51AM (#5916774)
I don't see mention of a 256GB limit anywhere. You also have 6 ports capable of 20GB/s, enough for way more external storage you'll ever need during the machine's lifetime.

The key in the new Mac Pro is extensibility (those 6 ports, each daisy-chainable). Thunderbolt is like a PCIe cable, you could add a better GPU, storage or whatever you wanted as external devices. It's much more open to third-party manufacturers than the current model of apple-sanctioned upgrades.

Re:Apple's New Mac Pro Begins Showing Up in Benchmarks by tracker1 on Thursday June 20, 2013 @04:29PM (#5914744)
I'm saying that the form factor would be better suited as a mid-range product with more consumer class hardware inside. As it stands, I don't think it will do very well.
Re:Apple's New Mac Pro Begins Showing Up in Benchmarks by dasmoth on Thursday June 20, 2013 @03:43AM (#5910756)
That's definitely how this looks.

If it turns out that there are actually a range of machines, with GPU options other than Firepro, this could still end up as a very compelling mid-to-high-end personal desktop.