Because it is highly inefficient, requires a large infrastructure, is susceptible to air pollution, and has low power density?
Versus battery electrics have infrastructure at every home, are upwards of 93% efficient, don't use air, and have plenty of power.
Wikipedia:
"They have one of the highest energy densities of all batteries ... an electric vehicle with aluminium batteries has the potential for up to eight times the range of a lithium-ion battery with a significantly lower total weight."
> Because it is highly inefficient
I just read in the 20 - 30% range. One, that's a lot better than a gas burner. Two, your magical 93% doesn't account for the efficiency of the source of the electricity. Over 40% of the electricity produced in the US is from coal. The average efficiency of a coal plant is around 30%.
Coal plants are also the #1 source of greenhouse gasses in the US.
http://tech.slashdot.org/story/13/04/23/199248/will-future-t...
But all I can really think about are electric supersonic VTOL jets. Which might crash if you fly too high...
> Can't imagine a 30k Tesla with this technology.
Sounds like Musk can imagine it. Don't know about anybody else but I'll side with Musk vs anonymous HN poster #5674.
> But all I can really think about are electric supersonic VTOL jets. Which might crash if you fly too high...
All jets crash if they fly too high. (Well, it's not necessary that they crash but they have a well defined operational ceiling.)
And the last statement was just referencing my ignorance about metal-air batteries working in oxygen-limited environments.
If the power-density problems can be solved, zinc-air or similar may still be a good idea. Zinc is, unfortunately, quite heavy.
Incidentally, I have put over 15k miles on my car this year alone. Some people drive a lot.
I just pulled up a number of around $1/kg for scrap aluminum. That's 55% of your cost. I'm sure that's wildly optimistic but that drops your fill up to under $10. That's in the ballpark of the electricity costs for the Tesla.
http://www.phinergy.com/
Takes a refill of plain water every ~200 miles and a swapping of aluminum at larger intervals. Aluminum is common as is the recycling of it. It's also a lot easier to handle than battery packs I would imagine -- lighter, safer, etc.
Not sure about the range but early press suggests it to be at least 1k miles between changes. I put around 4k miles on my car a year (much lower than average, I know). I take my car in at least twice a year for service so it would get half of them "for free".
Even at 12k miles per year that's only once a month. If it could be done in 15 minutes (a number I just made up) that's not much of a PITA.
I wonder what the cost would be vs gasoline vs the cost of buying a car packed with LIBs.