The difference between Scala and Clojure is the difference between ML and Lisp. Languages from the ML family are statically typed by definition, therefore they need slightly more features to be expressive. On the other hand, the trade-off is worth it for many people, because the compiler actually helps you - for example it's far easier to work with various functors (such as monads) in ML languages, than it is to do that in Lisp.
Also, Clojure is not "painfully restrictive" or "curated". Name one thing that Clojure doesn't allow you to do.
I would like reader macros because they would enable the implementation of sweet-expressions (http://readable.sourceforge.net/).
I keep thinking with Scala though, I'm going to run into some really awful looking code one day from someone overly abusing all of its features. I know know even the most restrictive languages can be abused, but it just feels like Scala leaves the window much more open for that.
I also keep thinking that, but it never really seems to happen in my experience.
That was also my impression. Clojure is sometimes painfully restrictive (I need forward declarations for functions if I use them before they are defined? In a compiled language in 2013? Really?), but at least it is curated.