Re:NSA Claims Surveillance Programs Aided Stopping Of 50 Att...
by tsotha on Tuesday June 18, 2013 @06:27PM
(#5902465)
>I really dont like the idea that because some people may have been saved from death that trampling on peoples rights is ok.
Isn't that exactly the argument inherent in gun control legislation?
Re:NSA Claims Surveillance Programs Aided Stopping Of 50 Att...
by dopamean on Tuesday June 18, 2013 @06:34PM
(#5902496)
Yes. I don't like most gun control legislation either. My only belief regarding gun control is that if we want to do it properly we have to repeal the 2nd Amendment.
Re:NSA Claims Surveillance Programs Aided Stopping Of 50 Att...
by privong on Tuesday June 18, 2013 @11:41PM
(#5903635)
This gets into the issue of where rights originate. Do they originate with the government (or its founding documents) or are they an integral part of being human?
Re:NSA Claims Surveillance Programs Aided Stopping Of 50 Att...
by dopamean on Wednesday June 19, 2013 @12:28AM
(#5903746)
I don't believe a right to bear arms is an integral part of being human. I think the 2nd Amendment has outlived its usefulness.
Re:NSA Claims Surveillance Programs Aided Stopping Of 50 Att...
by tsotha on Wednesday June 19, 2013 @12:39AM
(#5903770)
>I don't believe a right to bear arms is an integral part of being human.
Couldn't disagree more with this. I think the right to self-defense is very much and integral part of being human.
How many people died for us to end up with these rights? Thousands? Millions? Tens of millions? So is it ok to dash away 4th amendment rights to save hundreds? Thousands?
It just doesn't seem fair to everyone who sacrificed so much before us.