News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google challenges U.S. gag order, citing First Amendment by dragonwriter on Tuesday June 18, 2013 @04:44PM (#5901946)
> The government has a monopoly on violence.

No, it doesn't.

People who aren't the government, and who lack its sanction in doing so, apply violence every day.

Re:Google challenges U.S. gag order, citing First Amendment by gyardley on Tuesday June 18, 2013 @05:05PM (#5902075)
I don't know why you're being downvoted.

I'm certainly not the government, and I can quite legitimately be violent when defending myself from illegitimate (aka non-governmental) violence.

For example, if someone breaks into my home and behaves threateningly, I can (rather violently) shoot them, and the government won't object in the slightest. So much for them having a monopoly.

Re:Google challenges U.S. gag order, citing First Amendment by kaoD on Tuesday June 18, 2013 @05:20PM (#5902156)
Yeah but the world is not the USA. Some states DO have the monopoly of violence. E.g.: if you try to kill me in Spanish with a knife and I shoot you, I'll go to jail.
Re:Google challenges U.S. gag order, citing First Amendment by gyardley on Tuesday June 18, 2013 @05:24PM (#5902173)
Since we're talking about Google and the American government here, I thought the context of the conversation was understood.
Re:Google challenges U.S. gag order, citing First Amendment by kaoD on Tuesday June 18, 2013 @05:25PM (#5902180)
Sorry, I was editing and just addressing that :( It's a bad habit of mine. I moved the edit here.

Okay, I know that he specifically refers to the US (he mentioned Gitmo) but remember that even then the state is the one who lets you exercise violence. The monopoly's just lending some of its power to make you shut up and stop whining so he can keep minding his (evil) business.

Also: Windows had a monopoly even when Linux existed. Monopolies don't always have 100% of the market share, but they're still a monopoly de facto and will fight hard to achieve the full monopoly.

Re:Google challenges U.S. gag order, citing First Amendment by saraid216 on Tuesday June 18, 2013 @05:48PM (#5902287)
You can also be thusly legitimately violent in Texas if you pay a prostitute and don't get laid. It doesn't have to be illegitimate violence.
Re:Google challenges U.S. gag order, citing First Amendment by gyardley on Tuesday June 18, 2013 @06:12PM (#5902399)
I knew we could defend ourselves against theft of property with violence in Texas, but I left that out because it's not all that common across the United States - we're a bit more liberal with our rights down here.

What's the deal with the prostitute? Breach of services (especially illegal services) doesn't justify violence. Did the prostitute grab the john's money and then try and run off? If that's what happened, I'm not too surprised by the result, since we're allowed to defend ourselves against theft.

Re:Google challenges U.S. gag order, citing First Amendment by mayanksinghal on Tuesday June 18, 2013 @04:52PM (#5901987)
And they can be/are prosecuted/jailed/shot/hanged/poisoned/electrocuted for that by the government.
Re:Google challenges U.S. gag order, citing First Amendment by dragonwriter on Tuesday June 18, 2013 @04:58PM (#5902033)
If you have an actual monopoly on violence, you don't need to retaliate against other people using violence with your own violence, because there aren't other people using violence.

Now, perhaps the government has a monopoly on legitimate use of force (indeed, Max Weber used that as the criteria to define whether an entity was the government of a particular territory).

Re:Google challenges U.S. gag order, citing First Amendment by mayanksinghal on Tuesday June 18, 2013 @05:08PM (#5902093)
The legitimacy of an act (violence in this case) is highly subjective. The legality is a lot more objective. In this particular scenario, I think I would rather say that the government has a legal monopoly on violence. The legitimacy argument breaks down for oppressive governments where some revolting citizens take up violence because they see it as their last and only option. Some might argue that their act is legitimate, but it is still illegal. Now, one could always say that if the violence by government is not legitimate, it is no longer a government. But that is largely a philosophical/literary point. Here, when people are saying that Government has a monopoly on violence, they mean that the voters have granted them a legal right to do use force (which is at least pseudo-aggressive if not violent in all cases). The legitimacy can be contested in courts and debated upon in the next election - but till then, they reserve the monopoly.
Re:Google challenges U.S. gag order, citing First Amendment by dragonwriter on Tuesday June 18, 2013 @05:19PM (#5902146)
> The legitimacy of an act (violence in this case) is highly subjective.

In the sense Weber uses it, it may be fuzzy, but its not subjective (its essentially the aggregate of how it is treated by the people in the territory.)

> The legitimacy of an act (violence in this case) is highly subjective.

The idea that legality is objective in a way legitimacy is not is debatable.

> I think I would rather say that the government has a legal monopoly on violence.

Perhaps, but that seems to be a trivial tautology, in that what is legal is precisely, by definition, what is formally allowed by some government.

> The legitimacy argument breaks down for oppressive governments where some revolting citizens take up violence because they see it as their last and only option.

Weber would state that, to the extent that this is a general failure over some subset of its territory, the entity has failed as the government of that territory -- that, in the case where no entity exercise a legal monopoly on violence over a territory, there is no government, and in the case where there is such an entity but its not the one that is claiming to be the government, then the claiming entity is simply wrong.

> Some might argue that their act is legitimate, but it is still illegal.

In the eyes of the purported government that they are revolting against, but not in the eyes of the purported government that they have formed in the revolution. Legality has no meaning without reference to a governing authority.

Re:Google challenges U.S. gag order, citing First Amendment by saraid216 on Tuesday June 18, 2013 @05:52PM (#5902302)
So, this is the actual substance:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monopoly_on_the_legitimate_use_...

There is a lot more nuance there than the party-line recitation suggests.