News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Poll: Would it be OK for the NSA to spy if the code was p... by bdcravens on Tuesday June 18, 2013 @03:06PM (#5901292)
I'm sure there IS open source software being used. (Responding to question as written - was "data" rather than "code" intended?)

Of course, that means that as an open source author it's possible your code is used in what you might consider to be horrible ways. I guess this is true no matter what - say you come up with the world's next great web framework. You're a staunch atheist, but a Baptist church uses your code to launch a website to evangelize. Your code is changing the world in a way you oppose.

So... is there a place for a license with idealogical restrictions on use? Would this promote censorship, or would it restrict attacks on it?

Re:Poll: Would it be OK for the NSA to spy if the code was p... by chimeracoder on Tuesday June 18, 2013 @03:24PM (#5901401)
Such software would be non-free - an example of software which does this can be found with the JSON License[0]. The IBM team infamously sought (and received) a special exemption to do evil with that license.

The story is amusing, but the reasoning is simple: ideological restrictions are difficult to pin down legally, because they're murky to define. From a practical standpoint, this means that any company with a legal team that knows what it's doing will avoid using the software, even if their ideologies are in accordance with yours - the restrictions simply expose them to more liability than they're willing to take on.

[0] http://tanguy.ortolo.eu/blog/article46/json-license