Re:Rsync.net Warrant Canary (2006)
by dspillett on Tuesday June 18, 2013 @11:19AM
(#5899727)
> The government isn't allowed to
Argument lost right there.
As a UK resident my government is not legally permitted to take part in, or knowingly allow to occur on its territory, anything like "extraordinary rendition". "isn't allowed" made no difference in that case (and many other examples can be referenced for other governments including those of America) so we can't really expect it to in this or any other future case either.
Re:Rsync.net Warrant Canary (2006)
by dllthomas on Tuesday June 18, 2013 @02:26PM
(#5901046)
If it's legitimately the case that the government isn't allowed to compel you to lie, then they will have a harder time punishing noncompliance, which is significant.
Argument lost right there.
As a UK resident my government is not legally permitted to take part in, or knowingly allow to occur on its territory, anything like "extraordinary rendition". "isn't allowed" made no difference in that case (and many other examples can be referenced for other governments including those of America) so we can't really expect it to in this or any other future case either.