Maybe.
But, while we bought the iPad for many reasons, being able to draw by hand was not one of them. Paper enabled this in our household. Enabling consumers to create things is a pretty important feat. Introducing a new method? Me think it is worthy of some hype.
Parents have always found their progeny's output amazing. Crayon drawings are easier to put up on the fridge, too. But hey, iPad.
There's a fluidity and aesthetic to it that no other iPad drawing app has matched yet.
You mentioned you bought Paper and all of the in-app purchases — as far as I'm aware, Paper has always been free since launch (you can see this at its App Shopper link http://appshopper.com/productivity/paper-by-fiftythree). I think the IAP is fairly priced considering how much use I've gotten out of the app.
I don't have the writing one (can't see a use for it).
Perhaps it just doesn't suit your workflow. I still find the app remarkable in how much it makes me grab my iPad to sketch my thoughts. There's a distinct lack of friction to using Paper that allows it to take over for real paper.
Why blame the entrepreneur for media hyperbole?
Tech media lately is full of hired journalists from traditional(sic) media. Many claim to be tech journos but only a handful understand technology. Guess it's a pattern similar to how mainstream reports on Snowden rather than real issues.
A tablet with a bluetooth keyboard is what traditionally would be called a laptop, and thanks to several iterations of hardware and software, a modern tablet holds its own. Is anyone seriously arguing that people dismissed the ideas of laptops being productive, or that they thought that the state of tablets wouldn't improve?
Tangentially, Paper has got to be the most overhyped application in the history of applications. I mostly ignored it (after falling for the hype and grabbing it and all of the in-app purchases to actually have a marginally useful drawing program), but when they went on the road selling snake-oil about their trivial HSV "paint mixer" I really started to see the negativity in the hype.