Correct me if I'm wrong, but to theoretically record every single phone conversation in America would require unbelievable amounts of data storage, would it not? Even if it's stored in a highly compressed format.
The metadata I can believe, but I find it kind of unlikely they have the means to store the contents of every call.
http://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2013/06/evidence_that_...
Storage is cheap, and only getting cheaper. You could archive things older than a certain date onto cheaper media. Or consider converting audio into text-transcripts after a period of time, and you can dramatically reduce your storage requirements. Either way, $27 million isn't really much.
GSM voice codec is 9600bps = 1200 Bytes/s
x60 sec, x20 min per day, x365 days per year = about 500MB per person per year.
times however many people there are in the US, that's not a whole lot of storage and definitely a mere fraction of the NSA's data-centres.
Maybe not everything, maybe not now, but close to it and soon.
In fact I believe that the only reason our physical mail was mostly not read had nothing to do with the 4th Amendment, and everything to do with that it was logistically impossible and still have a working postal service, and difficult to keep secret.
With modern mail sorting machinery, I'm sure there is metadata being collected on physical mail.