I was left stranded as the check in time was 'organise with host', no specified time and the apartment location was a broad area. I had neither a time nor a place to check into, that's how I was stranded.
I had organised a Plan 'B' knowing this may happen so I didn't spend the night on the street.
I contacted AirBnb via their website a day before this event and still am yet to receive a reply from their customer support.
I think you're arguing my point any way, it's harder to be stranded from a hotel, either they will find you a room or they will point you somewhere else who can.
Special needs, traveling with others, just plain tired after a long trip, middle of the night, better amenities, better accommodations, hotels are booked full, maybe some of those available hotels/hostels are super shady and I don't want to be among strangers there. As much as I love the idea of being able to travel freely, I also like the assurance that I know where I'm sleeping at the end of any given day.
I've never used AirBnB and have no real plans to. However, I have traveled around Europe extensively, and some of the best times were when I simply arrived somewhere and then attempted to find accommodation.
I rode my motorcycle from London to Spain, toured for two weeks and never booked a single hotel in advance (my GPS packed it in on the second day too, so I played with paper maps). Only once was the first hotel I entered unable to find me a room.
I traveled around Sicily on public transport, mostly buses, a few trains and ferries. Again, I never booked accommodation in advance, always found somewhere and was never stranded.