News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Attention NoScript users by mustpax on Friday May 01, 2009 @09:50PM (#589423)
Very revealing. I stopped using NoScript a while ago since it would not properly whitelist some sites. At the time I was wondering why the plugin was updated so frequently with very similar change logs each time. This post explains why.

Interfering with other extensions' internal state is simply unacceptable. Firefox should consider sandboxing the browser extensions. Maybe they'll get to that after they implement Chrome style robust per tab sandboxing.

Re:Attention NoScript users by just_the_tip on Friday May 01, 2009 @10:39PM (#589466)
The plugin is updated frequently also because doing so lands itself in the Most Popular Add-ons chart. Giorgio has a history of pushing the limit to see what he can get away before backtracking when someone calls him out on it.
Re:Attention NoScript users by hboon on Sunday May 03, 2009 @08:09PM (#591604)
Sounds like an entrepreneur trait.
Re:Attention NoScript users by axod on Saturday May 02, 2009 @03:04AM (#589625)
>> "Interfering with other extensions' internal state is simply unacceptable"

Interfering with other websites revenue models is also simply unacceptable by using adblock.

Re:Attention NoScript users by jauco on Saturday May 02, 2009 @03:19AM (#589636)
No it isn't! I'm allowed to ffwd past comercials using my VHS and to cut out ads on my newspaper. Ads are a soft form of brainwashing, making watching them compulsive sounds too much like "brave new world" to me.
Re:Attention NoScript users by axod on Saturday May 02, 2009 @04:28AM (#589684)
>> "Ads are a soft form of brainwashing"

Every input we receive to our brains could be said to be a soft form of brainwashing.

Good advertising serves a use for consumers. Without it, you wouldn't be aware of what you can buy/do etc. If you want to opt out of that, fine. Personally, I find it invaluable to be aware of what is going on.

Re:Attention NoScript users by jauco on Saturday May 02, 2009 @04:37AM (#589691)
No, a constructive argument showcasing pro's and cons and highlighting merits of competing products serves a use for consumers.

And while that also has a soft brainwashing effect, it actually adds some information that allows you to make a conscious decission. An ad is just the brainwashing.

Re:Attention NoScript users by axod on Saturday May 02, 2009 @04:53AM (#589704)
Perhaps if you're particularly susceptible to brainwashing, then advertising could be a bad thing. But I think you have to give people a bit more credit than that. It's about giving potential consumers information so they can make informed choices.

Word of mouth is still the best form of advertising though - agreed. That's not to say other forms of advertising aren't effective, or useful for the consumer.

For example, I know what movies are out mainly through billboards. It's useful to me. If one looks interesting, I might look it up on the net and see if I want to go see it. I'm not being 'soft brainwashed', I'm being informed of a new movie I might want to go see.

Re:Attention NoScript users by shard on Sunday May 03, 2009 @04:32AM (#590730)
It's about giving potential consumers information so they can make informed choices.

For a long time now advertisement has been about manipulating people's emotions so that they seek fulfillment in the product being advertised. When was the last time you saw an Apple ad where the purpose was listing the specs so the consumer can make an informed choice?

Re:Attention NoScript users by jfarmer on Saturday May 02, 2009 @03:45PM (#590156)
How is that? It's my browser running on my computer. Shouldn't I have final say over what I do and don't see?

Nobody has a right to show me advertising, just as I don't have a right to read someone's content. If publishers have a problem with it they need to find a way to not display content to clients who are blocking ads.

But this isn't what we're talking about. We're talking about NoScript using my computer to interfere with other plugins. The behavior is unexpected and unwanted.

If the behavior is "ok" then the NoScript people shouldn't have any problem owning up to it, even broadcasting it to all their users. But I think we all know how that would play out.

It would be no different than if when you installed Firefox on your computer it made Safari break, or included some obscure option deep in its configuration menu like "[x] Break Safari."

Re:Attention NoScript users by lucumo on Sunday May 03, 2009 @05:12AM (#590740)
> How is that? It's my browser running on my computer. Shouldn't I have final say over what I do and don't see?

You're free not to use a site. But if you are viewing a site, why would you even expect to use it without also helping to provide for its upkeep?

> Nobody has a right to show me advertising, just as I don't have a right to read someone's content. If publishers have a problem with it they need to find a way to not display content to clients who are blocking ads.

Attempts which would be blocked by ABP's author. That would be an arms race. Maybe we should start fighting it, though. It would be much harder to maintain that they're not trying to screw over site owners with the extension.

Re:Attention NoScript users by twopoint718 on Saturday May 02, 2009 @08:20PM (#590356)
When someone pays to advertise they know it is a "leaky" mechanism. It is understood (or should be) that not every person in the world will see that ad. It is also understood that not every person that sees the ad will buy the products advertised. That's the nature of advertising.

Why do they still advertise? Because of the people that do see the ad, some do buy the product.

Re:Attention NoScript users by sho on Saturday May 02, 2009 @03:50AM (#589655)
"Interfering with other websites revenue models is also simply unacceptable by using adblock."

Why? I am simply requesting their content, and they are willingly sending it to me. I then process it on client side to my satisfaction, which happens to involve filtering out any ads.

If they don't like that, tough luck, stop sending it to me then.

Re:Attention NoScript users by axod on Saturday May 02, 2009 @04:33AM (#589687)
>> "If they don't like that, tough luck, stop sending it to me then."

It's certainly an option. It's easy enough to detect adblock, and send the user to a "Since you're not prepared to give us the benefit of the doubt that we'll show you a few useful unobtrusive adverts, please donate something or get lost" page, or otherwise degrade their experience.

For example, if the user has disabled javascript, sites should degrade gracefully. Likewise, if the user has disabled common forms of advertising, it'd be good for the website to disable any features that cost them a lot of money to run. Say it's a photo sharing site, give adblock users lower limits or something.

Adblock usage is a very small minority though, so unless you're a massive site (And want the very vocal minority to moan about how they should be free to leech all the content they want without giving anything back), probably not worth it.

Using adblock actually makes things worse for everyone. If you don't use adblock, and a site abuses your trust by doing popup ads, garish flash ads, then don't go there again. Stick by those principles. If everyone did that, then websites with intrusive stupid adverts would die off. By using adblock, you're rewarding those practices, but since you're never going to click on anything, the webmasters will likely make their ads more intrusive and garish to try and increase their CPM.

Re:Attention NoScript users by spkthed on Saturday May 02, 2009 @10:00AM (#589845)
The problem with your argument is huge. It requires you to basically have a whitelisted internet experience. Since most of the browsing we do is to new sites and new content, Adblockplus and Noscript have value in letting you evaluate the site first, then do whatever you want with it after.

It's a safety buffer and a very, very important one.

Unless you donate to the site/project or enable ads after that you are leeching content.

The responsibility for that goes both ways. If you depend on ad revenue for your entire revenue stream your business model is flawed. Let users do things like purchase the model outright to avoid annoyances or to donate. It's unfair to assume that a product won't be supported.

Re:Attention NoScript users by jauco on Saturday May 02, 2009 @04:41AM (#589696)
I'd be all for that. I don't mind paying for an increased user experience if I actually need it. This would kinda let the user opt out of the ad-based revenue model.

Unfortunately some people will try to hack it, tragedy of the commons and all that.

Re:Attention NoScript users by axod on Saturday May 02, 2009 @04:57AM (#589706)
Sure, it may turn into an arms race, although one of the other points of adblock is also that it doesn't download the advert - so it's extremely easy to detect an adblock user.

I think if adblock usage increases (I don't think it will), we'd move to a 2 tier internet - a degraded slimmed down internet for adblock users, and the full internet for everyone else. Which I think would be fair and just.

Re:Attention NoScript users by tetha on Saturday May 02, 2009 @10:14AM (#589851)
This will not work. A good adblocker will load the ads, but it will not display them. This is basically what my recognition center did before I switched to adblock (and had an improved internet experience due to (massively) reduced load times and no annoying, blinking things). The important thing about the last sentence: You cannot assume I actually react to something in the ad, and the ads are loaded, thus, there is no way for the server to recognize a good adblocker.
Re:Attention NoScript users by sho on Saturday May 02, 2009 @12:53PM (#590002)
"Using adblock actually makes things worse for everyone."

Well the thing is, no it doesn't. It makes things a lot better for me, because I don't have to look at ads.

But the funny thing is, I do look at ads, and quite a bit. Any site serving its own ads is not blocked. For example, I just went to railscasts.com and I saw a lot of ads - tasteful, non-animated, and I don't mind at all. What I cannot stand are animated or ugly ads, so I block them. So I had a problem, it's now solved, end of story.

"Stick by those principles."

But it's not my duty or interest to spend a lot of time like this, to "vote" for some sites and boycott others, to teach them a lesson. They have to figure it out. If they do, bring their ads in-house, and make them tasteful and relevant, then I wouldn't take any further action. But "fighting the power" like you propose? It's just not my battle.

"since you're never going to click on anything, the webmasters will likely make their ads more intrusive"

They can do what they want; I'm never going to see them.