News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Is There Anything Good About Men? by chaosmachine on Friday May 01, 2009 @08:57PM (#589376)
Despite the linkbait-ish title, this is actually a very thorough and well written article.
Re:Is There Anything Good About Men? by robertk on Saturday May 02, 2009 @02:05AM (#589604)
This is one of those articles that could be labelled "worldview changing." I mean this in the sense that to gain knowledge of certain facts and arguments has immense corollaries for how one understands and interprets the world. Here are two other recent examples I can think of:

- Moore's Law and the resulting implications regarding the "singularity"

- "Happiness" turns out to not be a Platonic ideal or otherwise specially-valued conception, but simply an ever-present state with slight fluctuations (and then perhaps "getting" happiness refers to obtaining the highest positive fluctuation--which will however stabilize over some time). See the recent TED talk on synthesizing happiness.

The key fact in this article, from which all other conclusions naturally seem to follow, is that males as a statistic exhibit much higher traits of extremity (in all aspects) due to the historically much higher probability of a woman being able to obtain a partner and reproduce.

Re:Is There Anything Good About Men? by iamelgringo on Saturday May 02, 2009 @03:20PM (#590128)
I think the author did have some interesting things to say. His idea of men going to extremes on either end of the productivity scale was interesting. His points that men occupy the top rungs of society as well as are considered expendable are interesting as well.

Completely disregarding centuries/millena worth of cultural, historical and legal issues seems a little intellectually dishonest, however.

Women have had difficulty for centuries across many cultures in obtaining property rights: http://womenshistory.about.com/od/marriedwomensproperty/a/pr...

Women have had to fight to obtain the basic right to vote: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Women's_suffrage

Women have also had to fight to obtain the right to higher education, work in certain categories of jobs, etc...

Dismissing all the cultural, historical and legal evidence to the contrary, and chalking it all up to evolutionary pressures seems a little dishonest. It's hard to evolve aggressive women, when aggressive women are imprisoned or killed. You still the effects of that in some very conservative muslim countries. I imagine that would have some evolutionary pressure on culling certain aggressive genes in women.

In fact, it seems dangerously close to, "well, men evolved to be stronger, therefore, only men should be able to be ['soldiers', 'policemen', 'construction workers', 'etc...'].

Re:Is There Anything Good About Men? by Darc on Sunday May 03, 2009 @01:16PM (#591016)
> In fact, it seems dangerously close to, "well, men evolved to be stronger, therefore, only men should be able to be ['soldiers', 'policemen', 'construction workers', 'etc...'].

Funnily enough, everytime someone tries to say that male ascendancy in society isn't a conspiracy by evil men to put down women, there is always someone who construes this as a moral validation of male dominance, or even as an imperative for it.

That cultural, historical and legal issues might have been side-products of gender differences rather than their cause seems to be unthinkable for the typical feminist kool-aid drinker.

The feminist ideology requires us males to be villains, because otherwise there is no war (because males aren't fighting it, and probably never have), and they become obsolete. Which is of course exactly what they are. Gender-gap in pay, academic and economic achievements, or even domestic violence have little or no cultural basis nowadays, so feminists are about as useful as slavery abolitionists would be today in western societies.

Re:Is There Anything Good About Men? by idiopathic on Monday May 04, 2009 @02:26AM (#592050)
> "feminists are about as useful as slavery abolitionists would be today in western societies"

In other words, very useful and laudable pursuits:

http://www.antislavery.org

The article is very good. Incomplete, but very good. Your response is disappointing because it dismisses the suffering of many people: women and slaves. Just because some university professor came up with a good explanation for the origin of suffering, it does not mean that the suffering is good, or that we should tolerate it.

Re:Is There Anything Good About Men? by Alex3917 on Saturday May 02, 2009 @03:59PM (#590168)
I wouldn't describe that as intellectual dishonesty. He might be wrong, but he's not trying to trick you.
Re:Is There Anything Good About Men? by jibiki on Saturday May 02, 2009 @04:11PM (#590180)
I don't quite understand what you are saying. What phenomenon are you trying to explain, and what is your explanation?
Re:Is There Anything Good About Men? by iamelgringo on Saturday May 02, 2009 @05:40PM (#590240)
It sounds to me like he's trying to discount the perspective that "men have kept women down" by suggesting an alternative explanation, "It's just genetic selection. i.e. men are more aggressive and care about dominination, women are more likeable and care about having families".

I think he is ignoring the fact that men have throughout centuries passed laws that did not allow women to own property, get an education, vote, walk outside their house unveiled etc...

Maybe part of the reason that women didn't build boats and sail around the world was because women weren't allowed to own property in many areas of the world, or because women were prohibited from obtaining an education and learning astronomy.

If you can't study astronomy, it's hard to sail around the world. If you can't study medicine, it's impossible to be a doctor or improve Obstetrical care. If you can't own property by yourself, it's hard to build a business. It's hard to be a political leader if you can't vote.

Re:Is There Anything Good About Men? by IsaacSchlueter on Saturday May 02, 2009 @09:15PM (#590395)
Isn't your response just whataboutery? I think part of the author's thesis is that misogyny is handled in numerous other analyses. However, even in situations where allegations of patriarchy are ludicrous, certain trends are still present. It is not necessary to catalog every true example of misogyny in order to argue against some allegations of oppression.

Maybe part of the reason that women didn't build boats and sail around the world was because women weren't allowed to own property in many areas of the world, or because women were prohibited from obtaining an education and learning astronomy.

Certainly, in some cases. But even in cultures where women are granted the same rights as men, certain lifestyles seem to be much more popular with men than with women; hence far more men among soldiers, death row inmates, and Fortune 500 CEOs. In cases where we notice more men than women reaping a specific reward, we ought to at least consider different preferences owing to biological/evolutionary origins.

But I see what you're saying. I would have liked to hear some discussion of the blatant and real misogyny that exists in the world. In fact, I would be fascinated to see an analysis of the situations you bring up, in light of the observed differences in gender attitude and aptitude.

Re:Is There Anything Good About Men? by raleec on Sunday May 17, 2009 @02:28PM (#613741)
You've hit on the logical fallacy that everyone seems to gloss over, namely, Men and Women are not different species. Any trait selected for would manifest in both genders. What this would lend credence to, is the cultural meme concept.
Re:Is There Anything Good About Men? by ezy on Sunday May 03, 2009 @07:19AM (#590778)
I disagree, I found it cliche'. It's a good blog-post, but not really world changing. Not to put you down -- I get caught up in these kinds of things too -- but what real evidence does he actually have to support his hypothesis? Sure, I could say that it isn't true because of this and that, but how valid would my argument be? ANgels on the head of a pin, and all that...

What he does is list a couple surprising facts, then invent scenarios to fit the evidence. It's one of the most common rhetorical techniques on blogs and in pop-science speculative books, and whether the author means it or not -- it can turn intellectually dishonest very quickly without adding clear qualification in the text.

I don't find this sort of stuff convincing or useful anymore. It's the same reason I have a natural distaste for Gladwell and his book-selling ilk -- this type of conjecture seems enlightening, and maybe you could get a few interesting ideas out of it.. but it's not supported. And in the end, you end up with stuff that's an interesting thought-experiment, but leaves you none the wiser.

Re:Is There Anything Good About Men? by Retric on Friday May 01, 2009 @10:21PM (#589451)
There was a lot of interesting ideas.

On the Titanic, the richest men had a lower survival rate (34%) than the poorest women (46%)

Somehow, I don't expect a lot of poor men to have survived.

Re:Is There Anything Good About Men? by aci on Saturday May 02, 2009 @10:23AM (#589858)
Titanic casualty figures: http://www.anesi.com/titanic.htm
Re:Is There Anything Good About Men? by vaksel on Saturday May 02, 2009 @01:18AM (#589579)
Thats the reality of the blogosphere, everyone uses linkbait titles now
Re:Is There Anything Good About Men? by anigbrowl on Saturday May 02, 2009 @02:29AM (#589611)
So it is, but isn't it a little more MetaFilter than HackerNews? At the same time I can't help a mild feeling of 'Say it ain't so, captain Obvious!' You only have to sit down with a good nature or anthropology documentary to see our social structures aren't all that complex or different from 'primitive' ones.
Re:Is There Anything Good About Men? by Retric on Saturday May 02, 2009 @07:59AM (#589797)
He actually talks about starting new company's so the link to HackerNews is not that hard to see.

But a more interesting link why men become obsessed with specific specializations. For a well understood example consider how many partners a highly talented and successful musician might have over 30 years. The long term impact of effective birth control will probably have long term impact on the most successful approaches.

Re:Is There Anything Good About Men? by skorgu on Saturday May 02, 2009 @10:56AM (#589888)
Already posted to Metafilter two years ago (along with, frankly, an extremely unproductive debate in the comments):

http://www.metafilter.com/64034/The-Waw-effect