News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Priced out of Paris by andyking on Monday June 17, 2013 @08:07AM (#5892678)
Even if my pay was doubled, I wouldn't be able to afford to live in or near London. However, I can afford a comfortable lifestyle in rural Yorkshire (house, car, holidays, internet access, good food, days out etc etc) on a modest pay packet. The rent for my 17th century cottage with garden in a Yorkshire village wouldn't get me a room in a shared house in an undesirable part of London.

I don't understand the pull of the capital. It's overcrowded, noisy and dirty, even in its 'desirable' areas. The oil sheikhs and Russian oligarchs can keep it. I'd much rather live up here even if I had enough money to live in London!

Re:Priced out of Paris by simonbarker87 on Monday June 17, 2013 @08:28AM (#5892744)
Couldn't agree more, I live in Newcastle (Upon Tyne) and wonder why all my friends headed down south after uni - for "the salary" was their reasoning but none of them have savings and their salary goes into rent, commuting and maintain an expensive social life. I'd much rather be here in Newcastle and be able to afford to live and save - just wish the weather were a little better
Re:Priced out of Paris by twic on Monday June 17, 2013 @08:38AM (#5892787)
It's great that you two feel that way. As someone who grew up in cities in the south and now lives in London, i'd rather saw my own leg off than live in rural Yorkshire. There just isn't anything there that appeals to me. Newcastle would be less scary - i'd only give up a foot to avoid living there.

This is not in any way a slight against either Yorkshire or Newcastle. Just an observation that one man's meat is another man's poison.

Re:Priced out of Paris by petercooper on Monday June 17, 2013 @09:29AM (#5892993)
Rxactly. I felt the same when, as a teenager, my parents moved from Surrey to rural Lincolnshire and I had to go along for the ride.

15 years on, I now love living in such a rural area (and also married with kids!) but it's pointless if you want to easily see the latest bands, have a large and sophisticated social circle, easily meet people you do non-rural business with, enjoy the latest in fashion or food, easily travel to other places without driving, etc..

On the flip side, I can easily go off roading, take my daughters to see farm animals every week, zero traffic jams, low crime, low cost of living, etc, so it's all swings and roundabouts! (And we even have fibre Internet, oddly, so it even ticks my geek box ;-))

Re:Priced out of Paris by simonbarker87 on Monday June 17, 2013 @09:46AM (#5893076)
Agreed, if you're smart then living in the south can be financially better. However I would say that my hobbies and interests (road and mountain biking) would be a lot harder in London - I grew up in Essex so appreciate the difference in the north and south - I'm not really interested in the social side of a city so that's another plus point to the north for me but for, many, a big negative compared to London.

A friend of mine recently moved him and his start up from London to Keswick and is loving it - it's all about aligning where you live with whats important to you.

ps. Given the love of football up here (sadly) you'll be needing that foot of yours!

Re:Priced out of Paris by gman99 on Monday June 17, 2013 @10:07AM (#5893191)
As someone who went to Uni in Durham and loves the countryside; (but still loved his two year stay in London), I can give you another reason: The sheer variety in cheap cultural things to do. I'm not saying Newcastle lacks decent culture, just that it's not cheap.

When living in London, I used to make frequent trips to The Globe (£7 tickets), National Theatre (£12), Sadler's Wells (£15), Museums (free) plus other great Opera's, plays, contemporary dance, etc all over the city, all for around £15 (usually a lot less) or free.

I've since moved out of London as I started missing the countryside, but don't be so quick to dismiss everyone who does not make the same choices as you do. The grime, overcrowding, noise & smoke of the city is more than compensated for by the amazing public transport and world class cultural events (again, for <£15 -- Newcastle has great cultural venues but even if they are of the same standard I could not afford to go regularly as it was more than twice as expensive)

I would never have discovered my love for Classical music, Ballet or Opera if the opportunities weren't so numerous and the tickets so cheap.

Re:Priced out of Paris by VLM on Monday June 17, 2013 @11:14AM (#5893632)
I believe you are missing a substantial scalability issue. From an article in The Telegraph "the Globe has played to 480,000 people this year". It seems to seat somewhere around 2000, so I am willing to believe that they have about 200 performances per year.

Living in the US I'm well aware of urban sprawl and the near inability to define imaginary borders. However for the sake of argument, wikipedia claims a bit over 8 million inhabitants in London.

Some long division and making the HUGE assumption that The Globe only permits admittance to locals (LOL I'm guessing its probably 90% rich tourists like myself) then the average local can only visit The Globe once every 16 years rather than your "frequent trips". If my estimate of 90% tourist statistics is correct, then the average London resident can only physically visit The Globe once every 160 years. Of course the average lifespan of a london resident probably does not approach 160 years. And there are more cultural activities than just The Globe. But lets say you want to do something every weekend... Personally I'd take the train and live somewhere else, but if you can find 160*52 = 8352 other equally cheap and worthy cultural activities then it would scale.

"I would never have discovered my love for Classical music, ... if ... the tickets so cheap."

For me it was free audio rentals at the public library. Back when they used vinyl and magnetic tape. They freely loan CDs now, there is a limit but its ridiculous like 10 loaned at a time. I used to visit my local library every week, but the local symphony only plays something like 8 different performances per year, so do the math there. In this modern era its trendy to claim people only want someone elses streaming selections rather than having a mp3 of their own and making their own selection decisions, regardless of how ridiculous that is, its also more or less free.

I live on what amounts to a very small landed estate technically in the suburbs, but somewhat rural. I visit Chicago roughly annually and soak in some culture. I'm glad I don't live there, so I can trivially afford to visit, and my tourist dollars are crowding the locals out of the very cultural activities they supposedly pay $3000/month to live nearby, while I pay about a third that to live in a vastly superior location about 100 miles away. You'd be surprised what a couple extra thousand dollars per month adds up to in the long run.

Re:Priced out of Paris by justincormack on Monday June 17, 2013 @12:00PM (#5893917)
It is actually pretty easy to find another 8000 cultural activities in London. There are probably 1500 permanent art galleries, largely free for a start.

But we are getting to one of those points where more of the benefits of a city should be transferable remotely. I would like to live outside London but the developer community is a massive draw. As well as culture. Also I am a native Londoner so it is home. But the cost of property is a huge issue.

Re:Priced out of Paris by gman99 on Monday June 17, 2013 @03:12PM (#5895257)
I used to go to the Globe pretty much every week (it's open air, so plays were only on in summer). One thing that I did not mention is the fact that the £7 tickets are actually "standing" -- I kindof prefer that as it means you're up right next to the stage. I always bought tickets on the day and they're pretty much never sold out (popular days/weekends could mean a fairly tight view :)

About scalability, as someone already said, there are so many venues available that pretty much whatever you wanted to do, there was always available seats for you -- just perhaps not in your first choice of venue (even after restricting your ticket price to £15 or less) Heck, as you're already in London and the public transport is free (you've got a travelcard as you have to commute to work anyway), you can go and do/watch/listen to something for free every night of the week.

Point taken about CD's in the library. But somehow even though I had the opportunity to take them out of the library before, I never made use of it. I guess I never knew I'd like classical music. But as the live performance was so cheap, I tried it and found I really liked it.

And now I live on the outskirts of London. I pay about the same in rent (bigger place) but hardly ever go into London. Mainly because I used to live about 12minutes from Waterloo and now it's more like an hour and a half (which means all trips have to be planned for weekends; as I can't really be bothered to head out after a full day's work)

Would I rather still live in London? Possibly not. But I'm definitely happy I lived there for a couple of years.

>>You'd be surprised what a couple extra thousand dollars per month adds up to in the long run

Well, like I said, there really is no change in my rent (but I now have a two bed flat and not a one bed), and I now own a car (additional expense). I've also stopped eating out, as restaurants are nowhere near as cheap as they were in London (expensive restaurants were a lot more expensive, but I've never found places that do £2.50 mains like in Tooting, for example) -- on the flip side I always enjoyed cooking, so this isn't a big deal for me. I am also living closer to work (as I work outside London now), so I guess my quality of life is better & the commute is less stressful (and the pollution is lower).

I'm just not as ready as you are to dismiss all the benefits of living in a city. But hey, we're all different. Just saying that I had a point of view very similar to yours until I was forced (SO's job change) to live in London for awhile. Now I understand the delights of living in London (but I can understand why others may not -- just wish people would give it a try :)

Re:Priced out of Paris by simonbarker87 on Monday June 17, 2013 @11:05AM (#5893572)
Fair enough, that is something I hadn't considered (nor realised how cheap it could be) - although I would counter to say that I wouldn't have discovered road biking or surfing (with a hefty wet suit mind you!) if I wasn't in the north east's easy access to both - 10 minutes on the bike and I am in the countryside.

It's swings and roundabouts I guess.

Re:Priced out of Paris by gman99 on Monday June 17, 2013 @03:28PM (#5895347)
I completely agree. I would not have discovered the joys of hiking and hillwalking if it wasn't for my four years at Durham (and "relatively" easy access to the Lake District).

Overall, my love of the countryside trumps cheap access to live plays/concerts/public transport/museums/etc; that's why I moved out.

My point is just that there are definitely reasons why people would choose to live in the city (reasons I did not fully appreciate until I lived in London)

Swings & roundabouts, as you say :)

Re:Priced out of Paris by rdouble on Monday June 17, 2013 @11:09AM (#5893600)
I've found the same thing is true about NYC. There are loads of free and cheap things to do. Especially during the summer.

Much more so than most other US cities, where everything is pay-to-play and you have to pay for driving and parking as well.

Re:Priced out of Paris by TheAnimus on Monday June 17, 2013 @09:38AM (#5893030)
Everyone I know in London who is < 30 (I moved here 7 years ago) has the same notion, that it is temporary.

The wages are so good here, so long as you don't blow it on a £2k pcm flat in a tendy part of town you can save a lot of money, very quickly.

Myself by having a 35-50min (depending on traffic and my exhuastion!) I find my accomodation costs are comparatively very low, despite still getting a London weighted income. This means I can not only service my modest flats mortgage easily, but am also buying a place in the middle of the mountains, so I can be a hermit.

Last time I looked outside of London, I would earn less than half what I get in London. I'm happy living in Zone 4 (where 1 is the central area), which means my rent is cheap. Going for a meal out or similar probably costs less than up north. At least comparing it to Manchester / Leeds / Lake District.

However, it is very non-terminal. I think five more years, then rent my London place, move either to subberbs and expensive commute, but house. Or hopefully, give up working for someone else all together. Not only did I meet my business partner via London network of friends, but also I built enough of a cash pile to be able to work full time on it.

None of those things would have happened if I was on £35k with £700pcm costs. I'll take £150k with £1200pcm every time.

Re:Priced out of Paris by njs12345 on Monday June 17, 2013 @08:35AM (#5892774)
If you don't mind me asking, how much do you earn? If you're on the median UK national income and you double it you'd very easily be able to live in a nice place in London. Your lifestyle would of course be very different, but not necessarily worse (I'd rather take good public transport than drive, for instance). Housing is the only thing that's objectively worse, unless you have kids, that is..
Re:Priced out of Paris by andyking on Monday June 17, 2013 @08:53AM (#5892843)
I work for a non-profit organisation and I'm considerably below the median income. There are jobs going, doing what I do for wages that are quite a bit higher - but they're all in London. An absolutely ideal job came up last week, but it's in Southwark. I just couldn't do it... so I stay here, where I'm reasonably settled and happy.
Re:Priced out of Paris by jzwinck on Monday June 17, 2013 @11:02AM (#5893555)
> The oil sheikhs and Russian oligarchs can keep it. I'd much rather live up here even if I had enough money to live in London!

And your government is making sure they do keep it, by "reducing net migration" of working people whilst granting a Tier 1 visa to anyone with one million pounds in the UK banking system. It's "pay to stay," and the offer stands at US $1.6 million.

Refer: http://www.ukba.homeoffice.gov.uk/visas-immigration/working/...

Re:Priced out of Paris by philh on Monday June 17, 2013 @09:00AM (#5892864)
> The rent for my 17th century cottage with garden in a Yorkshire village wouldn't get me a room in a shared house in an undesirable part of London.

Maybe I'm only confused because I've never lived in a village, but... You're paying significantly less than £700 pcm (including bills and council tax) for that?

Re:Priced out of Paris by drakeandrews on Monday June 17, 2013 @09:16AM (#5892943)
I rent a two bed flat with two other people in a nice part of Zone 3, paying ~£500pcm for rent and council tax (together we're paying about ~£1300pcm total).

I could quite happily rent a two bedroom cottage in the lake district and pay all my bills out of that £500.

Re:Priced out of Paris by lifeisstillgood on Monday June 17, 2013 @08:31AM (#5892759)
I keep banging on about how remote working will enable the spread of resort / rural living, and yet it is not quite true.

I am going to guess that you live within some commutable distance of your or your wife's family, and that one of the things you would lose moving to London would be that connection to family.

Its probably the biggest thing holding most of us from heading for a nice cheap rural life.

PS, apply for a grant from the Yorkshire Tourist board !