News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Golang Diaries I by laumars on Monday June 17, 2013 @07:11AM (#5892485)
Maybe Google is tailoring your results to bring back sites that include the programming language based on a) your past searching habits and b) the emerging trends for those specific search patterns.

Google's results are highly tailored, thus two people can search for the same term and get different results.

Going back to the original point raised, I too have gotten into the habit of searching for "go lang [query]" rather than just "go [query]" due to the same frustrations in the past. What the author describes isn't a unique quirk he's experienced, it's actually a very common complaint.

Re:Golang Diaries I by coldtea on Monday June 17, 2013 @09:06AM (#5892892)
>Maybe Google is tailoring your results to bring back sites that include the programming language based on a) your past searching habits and b) the emerging trends for those specific search patterns. Google's results are highly tailored

Well, tried the same thing logged out from Google, in incognito mode and with cookies turned off. Same results.

I can also try to proxy my search to a remote VPS I never use and see what happens.

But anyway, forget the "fitler bubble". Google is smarter that the naive "Go means the verb" in all contexts.

Re:Golang Diaries I by laumars on Monday June 17, 2013 @11:53AM (#5893875)
> Well, tried the same thing logged out from Google, in incognito mode and with cookies turned off. Same results.

Now lets try it with a search phrase that hasn't been hammered to death: "go http listener"

[1] https://www.google.co.uk/search?q=go+http+listener

[2] https://www.google.co.uk/search?q=go+lang+http+listener

In example 1, only 1 item on the 1st page is related to Golang. In example two, every result is related. (and that's without me dipping into incognito mode)

People like yourself and the OP can love to prove people wrong and argue that same popular searches work perfectly for you, but until you've spent a few months learning the language and thus making frequent searches online like myself and the author have, all you're doing is making pointless arguments (i mean does it really matter that much to you when you're not actively developing in the language?) which are based upon flawed experiments (as already discussed) and inexperience.

If that sounds condescending, then I'm sorry, but I've been working in Go for > 6 months now -so I'm still a new comer- but even just in that time I've noticed how poor the results are without specifying "lang" in the criteria. So I resent having a non-go developer tell me that I'm imagining the last 6 months of online research. Particularly when several (read: not just one other, but several other) Go developers have spoken up in this very same thread and confirmed the same issues I've been raising. This isn't some blip in Google's results. This is a genuine issue with the searchability of "Go".

But don't just take my word for it, here's some screenshots:

[1] http://armyofcrabs.com/google-go.png

[2] http://armyofcrabs.com/google-golang.png

Re:Golang Diaries I by coldtea on Monday June 17, 2013 @02:37PM (#5895029)
>People like yourself and the OP can love to prove people wrong and argue that same popular searches work perfectly for you, but until you've spent a few months learning the language and thus making frequent searches online like myself and the author have, all you're doing is making pointless arguments

Besides the BS ad hominem ("people like me", really?), you just reversed the whole argument against my results. How's that for contradiction?

People argued above that I was getting them because I was in a "filter bubble" for having searched for the language a lot in the past.

Suddenly the problem is that I haven't "spent a few months learning the language and thus making frequent searches online [like yourself]"?

What for? To appreciate the subtle nuances and variable results of using go vs golang?

Not to mention, I never said golang didn't work best (which you somehow assumed I did). Just that "go +stuff" worked well too.

>which are based upon flawed experiments (as already discussed)

Nothing of the short was shown. What was the "flawed experiment" and in what way?

Surely not that I was in a "filter bubble", because now you argue for the inverse (that I didn't perform enough searches). If that was the case, then you should be in a filter bubble too, after all your "frequent searches", which wouldn't explain your results.

Plus, I did the same from totally different account with no cookies and got the same results (as I patiently explained).

Re:Golang Diaries I by laumars on Monday June 17, 2013 @04:58PM (#5895916)
You're arguing the same points I'd already addressed in my previous post. You clearly haven't bothered to read my points nor look at the examples as they demonstrate exactly why "go +stuff" doesn't always work. So what's the point in me answering your questions again? You're clearly only going to ignore me, again. Just like how you've ignored everyone else that's replied to you.

> Besides the BS ad hominem ("people like me", really?), you just reversed the whole argument against my results. How's that for contradiction?

You're absolutely right. But I'm defending the author; and feel obliged to defend him because I'm sick and tired of reading lazy negative posts against authors who've taken the time to contribute back to the community. Particularly when a) the criticisms have very little relevance to the wider topic and b) the guys making the remarks aren't even experienced in the technologies they feel compelled to make authoritative judgements about.

This place used to be a safe haven from the trolls and egos of other communities, but these days if feels like the constructive and informative posts are outnumbered by the opinionated who have very content to contribute -and often, no interest in the subject either- but yet still feel compelled to comment.

And yes, I know I've swerved woefully off topic now. I'm certainly not trying to accuse you as being the worst that HN has to offer. I'm just frustrated that I've let myself get dragged into this dumb argument when I should have just broken my personal "down-voting rule" so that the healthier discussions in this thread could have risen to the top of the page.

Re:Golang Diaries I by coldtea on Monday June 17, 2013 @06:54PM (#5896514)
>You're arguing the same points I'd already addressed in my previous post. You clearly haven't bothered to read my points nor look at the examples as they demonstrate exactly why "go +stuff" doesn't always work.

If the "previous post" is the one I replied to, I not only read it thoroughly (and nowhere it addresses those points, you're welcome to correct me with citations), but also replied to it quoting you.

If the "previous posts" is something else up or down the thread, not addressed to me, then no, I haven't read it. Should I check and re-check everything in a thread?

Screenshots of what you got are not proof. I (and others) already said we got different results. So, it might not "always work", but it does work for some (contrary to what Tim says), and it's not due to a "filter bubble".

Heck, he WOULD be wrong EVEN if it was due to a "filter bubble", because then the lack of results would only be temporary, until Google learns his habits with regards to Go.

>But I'm defending the author; and feel obliged to defend him because I'm sick and tired of reading lazy negative posts against authors who've taken the time to contribute back to the community.

So you do it because you have an agenda, specifics be damned. I don't care if someone "took time to contribute back to the community" -- if there are points that need to be criticise they SHOULD be criticised. Not doing it would be a disservice to the community. Also, what he did as "contribution to the community" is just posted on his blog: not very different from what we do here, discussing in public.

>This place used to be a safe haven from the trolls and egos of other communities

Nowhere did I attacked the author. I responded to his claim and provided my contrary experience with similar searches. When confronted with the "filter bubble" explanation, I redid the experiment outside the "personalised search" effect.

You chose to come as a "defender of the author", attacking me, and talking about "trolls" and "egos". Maybe the problem lies with you?

Re:Golang Diaries I by laumars on Monday June 17, 2013 @08:47PM (#5896894)
No I don't have an agenda. I happen to agree with the author. And I also happen to think your opening argument was rude, irrelevant and wrong - in equal measures. Maybe not intentionally rude, but unnecessary none the less.

What's more, neither Tim nor myself said that Go never works. Just that Go is a lousy search term and that "go lang" usually yeilds better results. My screenshots are evidence of that (and your reasoning for dismissing them is completely wrong because nobody else had commented on those examples. So don't give me that crap about "and others")

The issue here is that you've decided to post the typical easy reps via unrelated negative, and did so by overstating the authors point about the quality of Go as a search term. But then, sadly, you were too bloody stubborn to admit when you were wrong despite numerous developers (read: people who actually know what they're talking about on this matter) politely trying to demonstrate that a) not all users get the same results, b) popular results for similar search patterns will be biased in everyones results and c) not everyone uses Google.

But who cares about experience and expertise when people like you can voice an opinion after only 5 minutes of button bashing on thier keyboard. who cares about the fact that several go developers have all said that it's just easier to get into the habbit of using "go lang", after recieving disappointing results in the past. And who cares that Google themselves advice using golang for searches, because obviously Google are less of an authority on this subject than you clearly are.

Anyhow, we're never going to agree on this and you're not even interested in this subject anyway. So I suggest we quit while we're ahead.

Re:Golang Diaries I by coldtea on Tuesday June 18, 2013 @09:15AM (#5898932)
>No I don't have an agenda. I happen to agree with the author. And I also happen to think your opening argument was rude, irrelevant and wrong - in equal measures.

"Enough with this old wives tale" was rude?

And yet you used: "people like yourself", "trolls and egos", "lazy negative posts", "you've ignored everyone else that's replied to you", "you're not even interested in this subject anyway", "people who actually know what they're talking about on this matter",

against my very simple statementthat his queries also work with "go" -- and it's not due to some "filter bubble".

Well, FUCK YOU, your insults and your condescending tone.

As for your points:

(a) "not all users get the same results" -- I replied to this, testing the "personalised bubble" effect. What else exactly do you think is in play? Divine intervention?

(b) "popular results for similar search patterns will be biased in everyones results" -- irrelevant, since I used the very terms Tim Bray tried. Why weren't they "biased" in HIS results? Isn't he a member of "everyone"?

(c) "not everyone uses Google." -- almost everybody does, and Tim for his examples used (and even works at) Google. Irrelevant again.

Re:Golang Diaries I by laumars on Tuesday June 18, 2013 @11:16AM (#5899703)
> "Enough with this old wives tale" was rude? And yet you used: "people like yourself", "trolls and egos", "lazy negative posts", "you've ignored everyone else that's replied to you", "you're not even interested in this subject anyway", "people who actually know what they're talking about on this matter",

You're selectively sampling data there. Those comments of mine are from later on in this debate - where you've been equally condescending. At the start I was polite.

> a) "not all users get the same results" -- I replied to this, testing the "personalised bubble" effect. What else exactly do you think is in play? Divine intervention?

Indeed you did. Albeit just the once. More tests would be required if you truly cared about disproving the bubble effect as your results could easily have fallen into the (b) point I raised.

> b) "popular results for similar search patterns will be biased in everyones results" -- irrelevant, since I used the very terms Tim Bray tried. Why weren't they "biased" in HIS results? Isn't he a member of "everyone"?

[sigh] Because they might not have been popular when he searched for them. His blog might have caused others to Google those terms and thus skew the results (in fact it definitely has caused others to Google his search terms as we're here arguing about it now). This is why I posted examples of other search terms, which you clearly haven't looked at yet. If you're not going to look at my examples, then why don't you try a few more irregular searches of your own.

In this whole argument you've basically taken one example as proof that your argument works every time. You've not even attempted other irregular search patterns of your own (or perhaps you have but they proved my point so you opted to ignore them as well?) so I really don't know how you can be so confident when you assert your point so absolutely. You do realise that multiple experiments need to be performed if you want to prove a statistical average? Just as myself and all the other Go developers have done with our time spent troubleshooting code.

> c) "not everyone uses Google." -- almost everybody does, and Tim for his examples used (and even works at) Google. Irrelevant again.

Of course it's relevant. You're arguing that "Go" is good enough on it's own - Google searches are just an example. If your point was valid then your results would be similar in other search engines. Later confining your point to one search engine seems a little like moving the goal posts mid-match.

Re:Golang Diaries I by alayne on Monday June 17, 2013 @01:16PM (#5894440)
Bing's results are much more entertaining.