News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Getting Real Value Out of An Engineering Education by graeham on Sunday June 16, 2013 @07:37PM (#5890544)
I think instead of knowledge memorization (like the periodic table), the author is refering to algotithm memorization, where the exam is testing your ability to reproduce the process of solving the problem. There is some validity to this in that it is possible to do well on an exam by reproducing the process without understanding the materials. Good examiners can write questions and grade in ways that support deeper understanding than algorithm memorization.

On the other hand however, education is about the process of learning. The advanced techniques used in engineering aren't immedieatly understood by many (any?) students. So the first steps in learning these techniques is mimicing existing work. Not alltogether different than actual engineering practice.

Aside: I do think time spent on student teams is very complementary to taught engineering programs, and spent 5 of 7 years in university doing Solar Car racing.

Re:Getting Real Value Out of An Engineering Education by munin on Sunday June 16, 2013 @07:51PM (#5890596)
> the author is refering to algotithm memorization, where the exam is testing your ability to reproduce the process of solving the problem.

and none of the higher-level courses I took in math or CS rewarded that either