News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Terms of Service; Didn't Read by thaumasiotes on Sunday June 16, 2013 @11:20AM (#5888708)
Some people have taller monitors than others. Some browse in different font sizes. There is no way, even in theory, of determining what was visible on screen.

edit: really, this is the exact same problem as "some people have taller screens than others", but some people have taller browser windows than others too. If I want to get some text off screen before clicking "I agree", it's fully within my power to do so.

Re:Terms of Service; Didn't Read by rossjudson on Sunday June 16, 2013 @11:26AM (#5888730)
I have been too successful muting my sarcasm. You are correct! My impractical idea is, indeed, impractical.

The point is that when we allow arbitrarily complex language to be buried under a single agreement action, a user has no idea what they are actually agreeing to. And everybody knows it. So we should just make such agreements null and void until the technology community (us) and the lawyers can come up with a way of breaking these user agreements down into digestible, understandable units.

Re:Terms of Service; Didn't Read by Silhouette on Sunday June 16, 2013 @04:55PM (#5889949)
So we should just make such agreements null and void until the technology community (us) and the lawyers can come up with a way of breaking these user agreements down into digestible, understandable units.

Which unfortunately destroys the Internet until that happens. Businesses typically don't enjoy the benefit of the doubt and consumer protection laws that their customers usually do when those customers sign up with a standard form contract where they have little if any power to negotiate. If a business offering a product or service isn't able to define reasonable terms to clarify what the deal is then that business can't transact with customers without accepting an absurd amount of risk or without negotiating individually with each customer at prohibitive cost.

When we did the terms for a UK business not so long ago, we were advised that things like hiding potentially unexpected terms away could weaken those terms if we ever tried to enforce them, while if certain terms that are reasonable but not necessarily obvious are emphasized then this can strengthen their enforceability. Also, there are some basic legal standards that any such contract would have to meet, e.g., where consumer protection laws say that certain kinds of term are completely prohibited.

This seems a reasonable fundamental policy: whoever is writing the terms can't rely on unreasonable conditions, and if there's something reasonable but possibly unexpected then it's in their interests to draw attention to it explicitly, but assuming they do those things their terms should be expected to stand up in court if necessary.

Re:Terms of Service; Didn't Read by knome on Sunday June 16, 2013 @12:58PM (#5889035)
Null and void seems extreme to me. These sorts of agreements do serve a perfectly good purpose.

While I would not agree that users should be held liable by terms as either criminal or civil infractions of any sort, they certainly work well to advise the user of what services they will be provided, under what circumstances the provider will be justified in removing service, whether or not the customer will be refunded in those situations, etc.

As a declaration of intent of service, potentially usable defensively by the company should a user take umbrage against the service, they are excellent. As anything else, they're pretty worthless.

Re:Terms of Service; Didn't Read by viraptor on Sunday June 16, 2013 @12:42PM (#5888970)
> There is no way, even in theory, of determining what was visible on screen.

There is - both in theory and in practice. Otherwise you'd get text drawn over other elements instead of scrollbars when you write too much text inside the edit box.

Re:Terms of Service; Didn't Read by thaumasiotes on Sunday June 16, 2013 @01:52PM (#5889230)
Doesn't the edit box's display logic run in the browser? If you get a POST request from me, how do you know I sent it through visiting your web page instead of from curl?
Re:Terms of Service; Didn't Read by mcintyre1994 on Sunday June 16, 2013 @03:31PM (#5889575)
In general, you don't. A common method to ensure it comes from a web page is Cross Site Request Forgery (CSRF) protection, which you'll probably want to look up if you're interested. In short, it uses a hidden form field sent with the data, and usually duplicated in a cookie. When you submit the form, the hidden field data and the cookie data are compared, if they match it can be assumed you posted via the web page.

Sorry if that's not what you were asking, and note there are lots of different ways to do this, that's just one example.

Re:Terms of Service; Didn't Read by pistoriusp on Sunday June 16, 2013 @11:27AM (#5888732)
I think you're missing the point and are simply suggesting the colour of which we should paint the bicycle-shed.
Re:Terms of Service; Didn't Read by kelnos on Sunday June 16, 2013 @09:02PM (#5890813)
Sure you can. The website author can check DOM properties to see the width and height of a particular element, and change the content (to add breaks and buttons) where appropriate.