News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A new lightweight lift cable will let buildings soar ever... by vidarh on Sunday June 16, 2013 @08:16AM (#5888219)
You seem to assume that you don't need to create and maintain costly networks for moving food, water and energy for people to live in rural areas. Not many people in rural areas farm their own food and sort out their own local water and energy supply.

Cities benefit because you can bring in resources using more efficient means in larger quantities.

Re:A new lightweight lift cable will let buildings soar ever... by maxerickson on Sunday June 16, 2013 @09:33AM (#5888363)
The availability of water varies regionally, but in many areas it is not a big deal to drill a well and have clean water (and septic is usually just a matter of meeting building codes).

Energy and food are still a big deal, but the mix today is that shipping fuel has less impact on food prices than real estate value (that is, the food at rural stores isn't particularly expensive and they usually aren't that far away). They may be less economical than city stores, but they seem tenable.

I sort of think the trick is to figure out a set of policies that lead to healthy medium-high density areas, as it is most 'great cities' seem to be at least partly accidental.

Re:A new lightweight lift cable will let buildings soar ever... by vidarh on Monday June 17, 2013 @07:47AM (#5892606)
> but in many areas it is not a big deal to drill a well and have clean water

Yet that is not how more than a miniscule fraction of houses in less densely built areas gets their water.

> Energy and food are still a big deal, but the mix today is that shipping fuel has less impact on food prices than real estate value (that is, the food at rural stores isn't particularly expensive and they usually aren't that far away). They may be less economical than city stores, but they seem tenable.

The real estate cost is irrelevant to the discussion of the efficiency of urban vs. rural energy and food delivery.

Re:A new lightweight lift cable will let buildings soar ever... by maxerickson on Monday June 17, 2013 @07:56AM (#5892640)
I was responding to you calling the distribution networks costly. If rural distribution ends up costing less, the efficiency isn't something you are going to get people to give much consideration.

This is why I then start talking about making more good cities, because that should presumably remove some of the costs that are more or less associated with lack of supply.