Re:NSA admits listening to U.S. phone calls without warrants
by vidarh on Sunday June 16, 2013 @04:32AM
(#5887861)
The slides claim NSA has access to company servers. It does not claim they have free access to whatever they want. A system of "dropboxes" coupled with a system to get specific sets of data onto them - whether reviewed by humans or not - could fit with that.
That would not contradict the Guardian reporting, or even what the NSA's slides claim.
The rest of what you state also does not contradict Guardians reporting: They make specific claims about specific subsets of these companies data.
You keep arguing about an expansive interpretation of the reporting even when faced with much more restricted alternative interpretations.
When comes to relying on press releases with denials, I'm clearly more cynical than you - I assign them pretty much zero value as evidence. I'd expect these companies to issue denials whether the claims are true or not, so I don't see the press releases as containing any useful information to draw inferences from.
That would not contradict the Guardian reporting, or even what the NSA's slides claim.
The rest of what you state also does not contradict Guardians reporting: They make specific claims about specific subsets of these companies data.
You keep arguing about an expansive interpretation of the reporting even when faced with much more restricted alternative interpretations.
When comes to relying on press releases with denials, I'm clearly more cynical than you - I assign them pretty much zero value as evidence. I'd expect these companies to issue denials whether the claims are true or not, so I don't see the press releases as containing any useful information to draw inferences from.