Ah, let me commend you on your effective and nuanced translation of the French original, "Le peuple n'a pas de pain ? Qu'il mange de la brioche." Very idiomatic.
So your solution is to tell labor that they should turn into capital? That is what you tell the millions of people who will be unable to find a job that pays a living wage?
Come on.
Progressive automation, it is at least arguable, makes that an essential part of any long-term solution. Labor as the key to income for the vast majority of the population may well not be a long-term viable option.
Of course, arguably, basic income / negative income tax is just an incredibly way of turning everyone into (at least, in part) capitalist living off what they own; what you own is a dividend-producing share of the commons. At a minimum, its a way of reducing the need to engage in wage labor to meet survival needs, and increasing the ability to direct efforts towards becoming a capitalist.
Perhaps that could even be a way to sell it to the populace so that it can't be immediately struck down as "worse than communism".
Labor is a market like any other. If it's too crowded and competitive, it's best to consider other options.
Couldn't agree more. Thinking that the only means to an income or wealth is labor a very limiting point of view. I'm optimistic about the trends toward entrepreneurialism and ownership, especially in technology. I think this is good for the economy and society overall.
What trends?
We are presently in a situation where our particular skills (which, incidentally, society has poured some resources into developing) are capable of creating things worth owning more efficiently than it can be automated. That is outstanding, but it's not necessarily sustainable.
If labor can't produce value, then people need to start out with something else.
However, the ancient fact that one's existence as more than a serf required ownership of something did not change. The living standards of serfs simply improved dramatically. Those living standards still depended on the demand for labor being high and/or the supply low.
When technology reduces the demand for labor, while the supply increases due to population growth, it's easy to think that the economic sky is falling. But since none of us have lived in a pre-industrial revolution era, we are accustomed to thinking of wage-earning labor as an economic strategy that is more common than ownership of property, and just as valid. But historically it has been a specialized and risky economic strategy, and as the demand for labor-intensive physical products decreases it should not be surprising if those who are dependent on this economic strategy suffer. It may be tragic, but it's certainly not a new tragedy.
If you want long term economic security, own something.