News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:It's not just metadata – the NSA is getting everything by marshray on Friday June 14, 2013 @02:12AM (#5878517)
I agree. There is no known attack on AES-128 which comes anywhere close to the capability of any known supercomputer within any reasonable time period.

Except maaaybe the aggregate computing power of the entire PlayStation Network for a long long time. I haven't run the numbers for AES.

EDIT: Yeah, no way without an algorithmic breakthrough.

Re:It's not just metadata – the NSA is getting everything by jacquesm on Friday June 14, 2013 @02:39AM (#5878587)
There is no publicly known attack, it is possible that there are undisclosed vulnerabilities in AES-128 that the NSA is aware of today. Is there any precedent for a weakness like that where an agency like the NSA was already aware of a weakness before it became public?
Re:It's not just metadata – the NSA is getting everything by marshray on Friday June 14, 2013 @02:56AM (#5878625)
A couple of cases come to mind where the NSA is seemed to demonstrate superior awareness of cryptanalytic attacks. But note that in neither case did the NSA recommend the use of a cipher that was weaker than the number of bits on the label.

1. Differential Cryptanalysis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Data_Encryption_Standard#NSA.2...

A general technique, but the DES standard turned out to have been developed to be resistant to it before it was known about in public circles.

2. Impossible differential cryptanalysis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Impossible_differential_crypta...

This general technique was invented and quickly broke 31 out of 32 rounds of Skipjack.

Schneier wrote in 1998 "I can't imagine that the NSA would field an algorithm with 32 rounds when they could break 31, so I believe that the NSA did not know about this attack. And the cryptanalysts are still working on improving their attack, so it is possible that they will get to 32 rounds."

But no one yet has.

Re:It's not just metadata – the NSA is getting everything by makomk on Friday June 14, 2013 @02:20PM (#5881492)
On the other hand, you're talking about ciphers that had short enough keys that they could be brute forced by the NSA. What's more, DES was invented back in the Cold War era back when the US's main opponent, the USSR, had better mathematicians but worse computing hardware, so making sure it was as secure as thwe number of bits gave the NSA an advantage. (Skipjack was just a fiasco full stop.)
Re:It's not just metadata – the NSA is getting everything by sesqu on Friday June 14, 2013 @02:59AM (#5878635)
I don't have sources handy, but I think I remember reading about several such cases from the 60's or so. They didn't really make use of the discoveries back then.