Re:The Guardian walks back claims of direct NSA access to se...
by XorNot on Friday June 14, 2013 @12:37AM
(#5878334)
They didn't say they had direct access.
The exact quote is "Collection directly from the servers of..."
This - depending on say, the context and narration, can mean any number of things and considering the intended audience and what PRISM actually is, would've meant "we collect this data that's stored on Google's servers" rather then perhaps "we seize individual computers" or wiretap the information some other way.
Which is a pretty obvious way to interpret those slides! But of course this is the NSA - clearly the first thing we must to is ignore the simplest explanation and start proposing hardware backdoors in Intel processor instead.
The interpretation wasn't extreme, it was literal. What it looks like is that the NSA claimed to have direct access while the denials that have been make it seem like they indeed might not have it.
The thing is that the NSA said they had this kind of power to someone, in a power-point presentation. They have said that they wanted it. And the regime of secrecy today makes it extremely difficult to determine for certain what they do and don't have.
I mean, if the NSA director was being truthful to congress in saying they weren't systematically spying, he's being very coy now when confronted with apparently contradictory evidence. Possibly, like many secret bureaucracies, the NSA was as wedded to telling someone, likely a high official, that they were ubber-powerful, and were by the token, attached getting the direct access even if they indeed currently lack it.
I mean, I think the NSA is discovering the weakness of secret approaches - that it makes all denials and all limits implausible. Hopefully, this will force a situation where all the "secret laws" and such get done away with.