News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Are Commercial Databases Worth It? by cschneid on Thursday April 30, 2009 @07:19PM (#587740)
I worked at HP in IT. We had literally hundreds of stupid little internal projects. Some were giant, some were 3 aspx pages. All of them used SQL Server or Oracle. But none of them came anywhere close to leveraging the databases.

I can think of only one app that was large enough and complex enough to really require a "commercial" db, and it was talking with SAP.... ohh, and it ran into constant problems.

What I don't understand is that other than features, the other argument is "Support". I have never seen microsoft get on the phone with a guy for free (yes you can pay...) and help out. But you know what, you can pay for a guy to help you out with postgres.

And you know, by going with proprietary databases, that cost so much money, there were severe restrictions on getting a database. They were in the hands of another team, who took weeks or months to get us setup. I know a part of that is server management, but another part was cost cutting on licenses. Remember that a small cause can have a very large effect in a corporate culture.

Re:Are Commercial Databases Worth It? by Zak on Thursday April 30, 2009 @07:32PM (#587759)
The "support" argument is almost always a bad one. Support for infrastructure products is never free; it's sometimes bundled with the license fee, but it's never free. Support is available in the form of paid consultants for any popular piece of open-source infrastructure. What commercial products DO have is official support, which provides some degree of consistency. Even that isn't a strong argument though; it's easy to tell good consultants from bad by asking for references.
Re:Are Commercial Databases Worth It? by chaosmachine on Thursday April 30, 2009 @07:59PM (#587785)
My limited experience with "official" support channels is that they're manned by people trained to be "tech support" rather than actual experts on the subject.
Re:Are Commercial Databases Worth It? by Titanous on Thursday April 30, 2009 @08:05PM (#587794)
Actually, I've talked with quite a few techs in Microsoft Professional Support that know what they are talking about. But you do have to pay a few hundred dollars per incident for that.

It's nice to know they are there when you're doing a hairy Exchange migration...