Re:How the US Government will Smear, Slight Whistleblower Ed...
by rosser on Wednesday June 12, 2013 @02:40PM
(#5869777)
As long as Snowden keeps himself in the story by giving interviews and making claims not substantiated by materials already released, he and his credibility are directly and specifically relevant.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:How the US Government will Smear, Slight Whistleblower Ed...
by jacquesm on Wednesday June 12, 2013 @03:54PM
(#5870317)
Ignore everything he says and focus on the documents released and let them speak for themselves.
Re:How the US Government will Smear, Slight Whistleblower Ed...
by trevelyan on Wednesday June 12, 2013 @03:56PM
(#5870327)
Snowden's claims are directly substantiated by the NSA document which specifies that the NSA has direct access to data from most email service providers.
Re:How the US Government will Smear, Slight Whistleblower Ed...
by threeseed on Wednesday June 12, 2013 @05:24PM
(#5870844)
Which has been categorically denied by the email service providers themselves and public statements from the NSA. So clearly something is amiss here.
Re:How the US Government will Smear, Slight Whistleblower Ed...
by trevelyan on Thursday June 13, 2013 @03:38AM
(#5872757)
Yes. Something is clearly amiss, which is why the focus on Snowden is -- as Juan Cole pointed out -- an irrelevant distraction seized on by those who wish to pull attention from the real issue at hand.
I also wonder at the technical naivity of those who believe that the NSA document must be wrong because Google and Obama have issued narrow statements in support of the FISA process. Because if we had to place bets, my guess is that (1) the NSA is either archiving all of the underlying data flowing across US backbone pipes and using this to reconstruct databases such as Google email archives, or (2) it has access to private SSL keys that let it decrypt content transmitted across SSL, or (3) it has automated the process of issuing FISA requests to the point where the process offers no sensible check on the abuse of power or protection of individual privacy.