News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How the US Government will Smear, Slight Whistleblower Ed... by tptacek on Wednesday June 12, 2013 @02:10PM (#5869576)
I agree with you that Snowden is himself irrelevant to the contents of the leak. But the raw contents of that leak are not the only thing being reported; Snowden is also making himself a part of the story, and making claims that are not directly backed up by the material that has been released thus far.

It's interesting that you'd call my comment "hopeless" and conclude your response by agreeing with part of it. Clearly, that must indicate some glimmer of hope. :)

Re:How the US Government will Smear, Slight Whistleblower Ed... by mbreese on Wednesday June 12, 2013 @03:28PM (#5870118)
I think that it's worthwhile to point out that there are multiple stories here. It isn't just about the NSA, and all of the aspects are news-worthy in their own right.

1) The leak that the NSA has been spying on people. If you've been following along for the past few years, the fact that they could do this isn't really news. However, the potential scope of the program certainly is. This is also the least well reported part of the story because only two organizations have the full contents of the leak and are only publishing select parts. I doubt we'll ever get a complete picture of the current NSA program, since so much of it is classified. It's hard to get corroborating evidence when you have to rely on intelligence employees leaking fragments of information. And, unfortunately, Snowden is really too low level of an informant to get a complete picture with context. His leak can give some ideas of scope and capability, but very little in terms of how the data is really collected, how often are US citizens caught up in it (mistakenly or not), and how the data is used/mined.

2) There is also the story of the leaker himself, Snowden. Who is he, what are is motivations, etc... Some of this can be found out with old-fashioned journalism, but a lot of it will be pure speculation. There will be a lot of reporting on this story simply because it's easier. Anyone can speculate about his motivations, and only a limited amount of people will actually talk to him.

3) There is also the rather more interesting (in my opinion) aspect of how the NSA and government's intelligence apparatus works. For example, how did we get to the point where a contractor can have access to the types of information that Snowden claimed to have access to. Why are there so many contractors that are extremely well paid? How much of US intelligence relies on outsourced work? etc...

4) Then there is the rather dull, but probably more important for society aspect of how much privacy do we (US citizens) want to give up in the name of security. How much oversight will we demand? This will probably be the least covered part of the story. It's hard and political, so it probably won't be covered nearly as much.

5) Finally, there are the international aspects of the NSA program. In the US, if you are a citizen or physically in the US, you are protected by the 4th amendment (with a few exceptions). However, none of the constitutional protections are granted to foreign persons or data that travels or is hosted in the US. I suspect that this will be the most covered aspect of the story internationally, but will hardly make a blip in the US.

So, my point in all of this, is to agree that Snowden is largely irrelevant to the contents of the leak, but that he, himself, is very much a part of the larger story. It's important to look at each part of the story separately, since while they are intertwined, they are largely independent stories.

Re:How the US Government will Smear, Slight Whistleblower Ed... by cheald on Wednesday June 12, 2013 @09:16PM (#5871769)
I think that Snowden making himself a part of the story was a defensive tactic. If you expect your government to not play fair - and he clearly doesn't - then getting your side of the story out into the open as soon as possible is wise. Otherwise, you run the risk of the propaganda machine spinning up and destroying the issue by destroying the man behind it. Being in the public eye also afford him some measure of protection against covert retaliation.

It's worth noting that Snowden has far greater knowledge of the score than the public does; the Guardian has many unreleased documents whose contents Snowden is obviously aware of. The fact that he's talking about things not directly backed up by what his newspaper contact has chosen to yet publish doesn't necessarily mean that he's making it about him.

Re:How the US Government will Smear, Slight Whistleblower Ed... by tptacek on Thursday June 13, 2013 @09:05AM (#5873793)
You think it's going to turn out to be likely that Snowden could have read Obama's emails?
Re:How the US Government will Smear, Slight Whistleblower Ed... by cheald on Thursday June 13, 2013 @12:41PM (#5874993)
As stated, absolutely. He qualified it with a "personal email address". Saying "Oh yeah, I could read the president's personal email" is just playing up the impact of the program by throwing a high-value name behind the assertion. The information there is that they can read personal email; the president's personal email isn't more technologically protected than anyone else's given the same provider.
Re:How the US Government will Smear, Slight Whistleblower Ed... by subsystem on Wednesday June 12, 2013 @02:16PM (#5869612)
"making claims that are not directly backed up by the material"

Which makes those claims inconclusive regardless of Snowdens character.

Re:How the US Government will Smear, Slight Whistleblower Ed... by XorNot on Wednesday June 12, 2013 @02:58PM (#5869897)
Except where - particularly around Hacker News - people have been taking everything Snowden has said and just running with it as though it's obviously true, regardless of technical or legal possibility.

The material that's actually been disclosed is, what, 3 powerpoint slides? Almost everything else is simply wild speculation.

Re:How the US Government will Smear, Slight Whistleblower Ed... by subsystem on Wednesday June 12, 2013 @03:35PM (#5870186)
As far as I know it's 5 slides on PRISM, 4 slides and screenshots on BOUNDLESSINFORMANT and a Verizon court order from FISC.
Re:How the US Government will Smear, Slight Whistleblower Ed... by tptacek on Wednesday June 12, 2013 @02:54PM (#5869861)
I guess if you're going to stipulate that nobody believes anything Snowden says and that we're all sticking to the leaked Powerpoint slides, sure.
Re:How the US Government will Smear, Slight Whistleblower Ed... by mbreese on Wednesday June 12, 2013 @03:30PM (#5870144)
Which in and of itself is tricky because a slidedeck without the presentation itself is hard to interpret. I don't know how much of the slidedeck is historical vs aspirational. And who made the slides in the first place - did they have a better picture of the program than Snowden?
Re:How the US Government will Smear, Slight Whistleblower Ed... by tptacek on Wednesday June 12, 2013 @03:33PM (#5870159)
If I'm being asked who I believe more, the person who authored a slide deck selling some kind of surveillance tool to the NSA, or Google's chief architect, their general counsel, and Larry Page, I'm going to go with the Googlers.
Re:How the US Government will Smear, Slight Whistleblower Ed... by subsystem on Wednesday June 12, 2013 @04:08PM (#5870386)
"PRISM Collection Manager", "April 2013", "ORCON", "You should use both" and the classification date in relation to the date slide doesn't suggest sales material to me.

Note that the slides have different degrees of redaction across sources. These links should together cover what's available on PRISM.

http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2013/jun/06/us-tech-giants-n... http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-srv/special/politics/prism-... http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2013/jun/08/nsa-prism-server...

Re:How the US Government will Smear, Slight Whistleblower Ed... by tptacek on Wednesday June 12, 2013 @06:13PM (#5871074)
You know what: stipulate that this is an internal presentation by a manager at NSA. My opinion is unchanged about who's more credible.
Re:How the US Government will Smear, Slight Whistleblower Ed... by subsystem on Wednesday June 12, 2013 @06:50PM (#5871224)
A collection manager is someone who works with collection management and not necessarily a manager, as in boss.
Re:How the US Government will Smear, Slight Whistleblower Ed... by mbreese on Wednesday June 12, 2013 @03:44PM (#5870247)
Exactly. Google at least has some room for transparency in all of this. Not to mention an economic incentive to get an accurate picture of this out in the public.

Google has motivation to bring clarity to their role in all of this. The NSA would rather keep everything secret. I'd believe Google more too...

Re:How the US Government will Smear, Slight Whistleblower Ed... by thwest on Thursday June 13, 2013 @03:11AM (#5872707)
On what basis? Personality?
Re:How the US Government will Smear, Slight Whistleblower Ed... by jcc80 on Wednesday June 12, 2013 @02:54PM (#5869862)
"Snowden is also making himself a part of the story, and making claims that are not directly backed up by the material that has been released thus far."

So why not ignore the noise & leave it for the gossip pages while focussing on the bigger picture?

Re:How the US Government will Smear, Slight Whistleblower Ed... by tptacek on Wednesday June 12, 2013 @02:56PM (#5869874)
Because the noise is being reported as if it was fact?
Re:How the US Government will Smear, Slight Whistleblower Ed... by gte910h on Wednesday June 12, 2013 @09:50PM (#5871843)
> Snowden is also making himself a part of the story

To not be vanished. Come on man.

Re:How the US Government will Smear, Slight Whistleblower Ed... by tptacek on Wednesday June 12, 2013 @11:01PM (#5872067)
What does telling the Washington Post that he had access to President Obama's email have to do with being vanished?
Re:How the US Government will Smear, Slight Whistleblower Ed... by gte910h on Thursday June 13, 2013 @06:54PM (#5877151)
Do you know he said that?

My experience with reporters (and news producers) is that they get you to say things under one pretense, and it gets swung around with little empathy towards another to tell the story they want to tell (not necessarily out of malice, often just because they want to tell a different story than the facts do).

I'm not claiming he's some sort of saint and he's accurate (or even sure) of all that he's saying, but I'm sure reporters are eating him for lunch and pulling all sorts of shit out of him.

He had to give interviews to raise his profile enough for questions to be asked if he vanished to pre-empt those attempts.