News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The problem with GNOME 3 by smacktoward on Wednesday June 12, 2013 @01:14PM (#5869224)
The biggest problem with relying on a survey of users to determine what direction a software project should go is that users don't know what they want.

Or rather, they know it, but only deep down in their subconscious, their lizard brain. Their conscious mind doesn't know, because you're asking them to pull specific things out of the nebulous cloud of the possible, and there's too many of the damn things in that cloud for them to know which ones map to what they want.

That's why they need developers. Developers know how to translate requirements into features. Users don't. And they shouldn't have to!

So if you ask them, what you get back tends to be:

- too vague ("it should be easier");

- pie-in-the-sky stuff ("it should whiten my teeth while I use it");

- or falling back on what they know, which is what they've had in the past ("bring back feature X").

If you want to learn what users want, you have to watch them use the product, pick up on their frustrations, and creatively solve them. Asking them what they want leads you nowhere.

Re:The problem with GNOME 3 by notacoward on Wednesday June 12, 2013 @01:27PM (#5869296)
You just skimmed the article before rushing to have the first comment here, right? It explicitly addresses the "users don't know what they want" excuse, for several paragraphs. Also, developers are only barely better at translating requirements into features than users are, and that's even one of the ways GNOME has screwed up. Where are the UX designers? Where are the product managers? In any project large enough to have some of those - like GNOME is - it's primarily their job to do that translation. They should be the ones watching and engaging with users, while the developers mostly - wait for it - develop. Leaving both kinds of user interaction to developers is exactly how you get to where GNOME is today.
Re:The problem with GNOME 3 by vegasje on Wednesday June 12, 2013 @01:18PM (#5869249)
As mentioned in the article, you are correct in saying that users don't know what they want. However, they darn sure know what they _don't_ want, which is why many of the complaints are completely valid.
Re:The problem with GNOME 3 by jamesgeck0 on Wednesday June 12, 2013 @02:25PM (#5869683)
Well, sort of. Users of an existing application tend to cling to the old version in the event of a major UI overhaul, even if the new version is easier to use.

For example, Microsoft Office 2007 came out just after I started university. I'd never used Office before, and I spent a lot of time digging around in Office 2003's menus looking for things. I'd googled for help using programming languages before, but googling for help about an office suite seemed strange.

When I tried Office 2007, I thought that the tabbed interface was fantastic; I had a far easier time finding the options and features I was looking for. The more I used it, the more impressed I was at how intuitive Microsoft had made it.

My father had been using Office for decades. I excitedly showed him the new version and installed it alongside his older version so that he could open the docx files that people were starting to send him.

He _hated_ it. For over a year afterward, I heard about how terrible it was and how he had to unlearn everything and how he couldn't find anything. I even heard that all his keyboard shortcuts were broken, even though that wasn't one of the things that changed and even though he couldn't demonstrate any that no longer worked.

Users know what they don't want, and they really don't want change.

Re:The problem with GNOME 3 by EdiX on Wednesday June 12, 2013 @03:29PM (#5870134)
Yes, of course, everyone who doesn't like a major UI overhaul is just an irrational luddite. New UI is always better UI.

However you got one thing right: familiarity always trumps ease of learning, ie. the easiest thing to learn is what you know already. So if you define "good UI" as "user friendly UI" (as we have done, for some reason, for 30 years) you will find that the best UI is always the old one, because virgin users do not exist anymore.

Re:The problem with GNOME 3 by felipec on Wednesday June 12, 2013 @03:03PM (#5869926)
> He _hated_ it.

We still do.