The author here. I understand that some people have no problems with GNOME 3, that's fine. Based on the evidence I've gathered through the years, my estimate is that half the people that used GNOME 2 liked GNOME 3, and half didn't. In my opinion that's way too many people to piss off in one version bump.
Judging from the responses after two years from the debacle, I think it's fair to say that GNOME will never be as successful as it once was.
And I was all about configuration in Gnome 2... Gnome 3 is definitely not like Gnome 2's tweaker's paradise. It was an effort to strip down to a minimalistic GUI and, after a rough start, they've done quite well. I've not missed the "Start" menu at all. I've not missed all the configuration/tweaking. I appreciate the functionality exposed by the Windows button. I've gotten used to Alt-` for switching windows-within-applications.
But I definitely agree with the author's points about the Gnome devs' response to feedback. Without regard to the trajectory of Gnome 3, the developers seems not to have managed or responded to criticism well. And Gnome 3 development and direction has been fairly quiet from a PR perspective, and a bit more PR/blog-posts could have been effective and mollifying the haters.
Note: I don't really use multiple workspaces, so can't comment on the author's comments there.