Not engaging in an arms race with well funded, very smart, government agencies is probably a good idea.
If they think you're a criminal (doesn't apply to Mozilla) they will coerce foreign governments to cooperate - see for example the illegal attacks on Mega or the domain seizures for gambling or torrent sites.
But we know, from ECHELON, that they're happy to spy on anyone, and use weird loopholes in the law to do so.
Mozilla would need to find a country that had great Internet infrastructure; good strong laws and privacy culture[1]; lack of links to US; comfortable living for staff; etc etc.
That's not easy.
[1] The US has a strong culture of privacy, which is what makes PRISM so surprising for their citizens. (Not for many other people who were saying it's happening, and have been doing so for a while.)
"[1] The US has a strong culture of privacy, which is what makes PRISM so surprising for their citizens. (Not for many other people who were saying it's happening, and have been doing so for a while.)"
When will the public accept that "good strong laws and privacy culture" is not in the least a characteristic of the US, and hasn't been for the last 30 years?
The US is probably not a democracy anymore, and hasn't been for over 20 years, since Governments are elected by corporate interests (via campaign funding)
But that's not enough. If they really want to be free from the US's reach they'd have to:
- not do business with any companies under US jurisdiction (oops - Google and Microsoft)
- not employ and US citizens or permanent residents
- warn employees that they could get arrested if they visit the US
- ...
And given that Firefox is a very visible browser with significant market share, the US government would probably be very motivated to squash outright defiance.
How much of Mozilla would be left to do that again?
The other option is to contribute to educate the public by being honest. Giving the false hopes that they provide in their statement, they are doing a disservice to the public by downplaying the risk posed by the government.
I would have hoped from more honesty from Mozilla; they should just call it what it is: the US is a police state, so you'd better protect yourself.
If they want to be able to store a bit of customer information that they don't have to pass over to the US government then they just have to move the company and their servers out of the US.
Why would a company that has nothing to do with the US have to warn employees that they could get arrested if they visit the US?
You might not know why, but they do. The US is unusually (perhaps uniquely) aggressive in how far it tries to push the reach of its law. It's worth thinking through the implications of that.
I read "This is a race we'll probably not win and even if we do, we'd have a lot of power tied up there. But we can win by just changing the rules, so let's do that."
The only way to stop this, until privacy technology is widespread (which I hope will become a huge topic soon), is to stop doing business in the US right now.
Thus, the stated goal of persona is to remove the need for a centralized auth provider - thus sidestepping the problem of where those centralized servers are located. That's why they don't want to engage in a whack-a-mole game with the US government.
> Read: we are afraid to lead here...
Both the non-profit and for-profit arms of Mozilla are funded almost entirely by Google. It's a pretty safe bet that they'll follow Google's overall lead in dealing with the government.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mozilla_Foundation - "funded almost exclusively by Google Inc."
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mozilla_Corporation - "Google pays Mozilla a substantial sum – in 2006 the total amounted to around $57 million, or 85% of the company’s total revenue. [The deal was extended multiple times and currently expires in November 2014.]"
Microsoft also probably has some interest in supporting Firefox for "browser strategic" reasons (pushing back against WebKit/Blink on mobile, a partner other than Google or Apple for work with on new web standards, etc.). I find it harder to imagine Apple being interested, but perhaps that would change if Blink starts eclipsing WebKit or if they want to push iAds more. More generally, though, the point I'm making is that (almost?) all potential alternative sponsors have extensive US ties and/or interests...
Well, it is clear the US has it. That should be enough. There are some unknowns unknowns, but this is a known unknown. There are other governments with the same willingness and capabilities of spying on everyone (do not move to China), but most of the countries in the world do not have a Government with both willingness and the technical abilities to do it. And most of the countries do not have a huge and highly sophisticated shadow-government, with multiple agencies working out of the public oversight. Most countries have secret services, but they are a joke compared to what the US is able to deliver.
"Second, as a US company, Mozilla is subject to US Laws, wherever we host our servers."
Move the company out of the US. I undertsand that it won't be easy, but is the only way to be 100% sure that the US Government will not come requesting data (not that they will not take it anyway, if they are able to)
"Third, we’d rather not engage in an arms-race with US government agencies."
Read: we are afraid to lead here, because backlash from the government (and the public?) could be too damaging for Mozilla.
"We’d rather focus on efforts to change the Law to respect user data wherever it lives."
We know so much: the privacy situation in the US is bad, and getting worse very fast. No amount of public discussion or legislation is going to change that. If PRISM is outlawed, even if those responsible are put into prison, they will start the PROSM program, more secretive, more broad. We will know about it on 2037 (maybe not, since by then we will be already living in a fully accomplished Orwell world). By then Mozilla will issue a statement similar to this one, explaining why they are not really taking the necessary steps.
Fazit: if even a company committed to freedom and openness like Mozilla is not willing and/or able to take the necessary steps, it shows how unavoidable 1984 is.