News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:iOS 7 looks familiar by shurcooL on Tuesday June 11, 2013 @03:34PM (#5864204)
I don't understand this obsession with complaining about copying or imitating in design. As long as good things are taken and worse things are left behind, the consumers benefit.

It's like being upset that the 2014 cars have the same steering wheel and pedal layout, or that a manufacturer "stole" the idea of using a USB port in a car.

Re:iOS 7 looks familiar by tolmasky on Tuesday June 11, 2013 @04:00PM (#5864338)
I can't speak for other people, but I can perhaps share some insight from my feelings. Just to get it out of the way, it is a bit annoying to see a company that is normally absolutely obsessed with others copying them now doing the same. But as eyebrow raising as that is, its not really my main concern.

My personal issue with this design is that it signals the coming of a boring lull in mobile design. Its the death of distinction. Android, Windows, and iPhone now largely look the same (to me). In fact I think the Windows stuff actually looks better. Its upsetting because there are surely more than just two possible designs ("flat" or "skeuomorphic"). Did iOS need a design overhaul? I don't know (I'm personally of the belief that it was missing key features and services more than a new skin). But if for the sake of argument it did, then this just frankly feels lazy on Apple's part. It was the most obvious direction to go in, and its been done. Aqua and iOS 1 were different, fresh, and represented an original vision for UIs. Even if you didn't like them it provided something to contrast to. This just provides something to compare to :/

Re:iOS 7 looks familiar by Finster on Tuesday June 11, 2013 @04:21PM (#5864471)
I feel like your argument basically distills down to: "All flat designs look alike."

Surely, that's not the case. And as I've been messing around with IOS7, I'm noticing a lot more than just a graphical redesign. This is also a usability redesign. Little things like including a contact button at the top of the Messages app itself rather than at the top of the message view. IOS7 is full of these little tweaks that have been standard fare in the jailbreak communities.

To boil it down to "a boring lull in mobile design" is to really ignore the quality of the IOS7 redesign.

Re:iOS 7 looks familiar by tolmasky on Tuesday June 11, 2013 @05:05PM (#5864726)
I think you may have made my point better than I did: I'm just not that impressed with Apple finally cribbing off the jailbreak community, and I sincerely hope that the future of iOS is not endless tweaking held up as some paramount of interaction design. Am I happy with these changes? Sure, the same way I'm happy that Mac OS X has finally fixed the multiple-display bug that has plagued it for 3 years. But these (long overdue) changes a bold OS do not make. And perhaps the argument is that Apple is not trying to make a bold new OS. However, that is definitely what it is presenting iOS 7 as, so I feel that I have a right to disagree.

I think the community in general has felt that iOS 7 was Apple's chance to respond to the criticisms (fair or not) that iOS was stagnating, and I feel that that is what Apple feels it has accomplished. I feel they have done so in the shallowest way possible. To me they presented a corporate image of playing catchup: catching up to Windows and Android visual design cues, catching up to jailbreak experiments that have been happening for years, catching up to interactions we saw in Web OS ages ago. I'm not saying they shouldn't have done this, I'm saying that in my eyes these are bug fixes and there exists an Apple that pushed further. There are a million things I wish Safari did every single day that I use it, and quite frankly "3d tab organization" is not one of them.

This is my point, I think people are not seeing the actual usability improvements that could have taken place. You think design is more than just visual stuff, its usability. I agree, I just think its more than making things take 3 taps less. Remember the original iPhone and iOS, it was a completely different way of interacting with your phone that allowed you to do NEW things you couldn't before. Google is now exploring real new territory with their excellent services like Google Now. If Apple wants to keep fighting services and infrastructure with "design", that's fine, but its going to require more than endlessly spinning its wheels trying to figure out the "best" weather interface possible and micro-optimizing insignificant interactions with the OS.

Re:iOS 7 looks familiar by gfodor on Tuesday June 11, 2013 @05:17PM (#5864778)
Have you actually used the beta or are you another person basing opinions about an operating system based upon screenshots?
Re:iOS 7 looks familiar by nnnnni on Wednesday June 12, 2013 @08:28AM (#5867703)
"I'm just not that impressed with Apple finally cribbing off the jailbreak community, and I sincerely hope that the future of iOS is not endless tweaking held up as some paramount of interaction design."

I see the jailbreak tweaks as the alpha version of features that will one day make it into the main source. People who are not afraid to test things out play with and refine the tweaks until they're ready to be official.

I love the fact that at least eight tweaks have been integrated into the main source!

Re:iOS 7 looks familiar by LowKarmaAccount on Tuesday June 11, 2013 @07:05PM (#5865312)
I'm surprised that many of the little tweaks that Apple has added weren't available sooner. For example, on iOS 5 you could adjust the screen brightness via the double-click home menu on the bottom on the iPad, but not on the iPod, which was bizarre.
Re:iOS 7 looks familiar by rdouble on Tuesday June 11, 2013 @04:05PM (#5864371)
After a morning playing with it, it doesn't really look or feel anything like Windows phone to me. I don't have enough experience with Android to offer much in useful commentary, but it doesn't seem like the Nexus 7 I once used. Has anyone put up a side by side compare and contrast against the other mobile OSes yet? I suppose that would be against the dev agreement.
Re:iOS 7 looks familiar by sjwright on Wednesday June 12, 2013 @05:51AM (#5867309)
I don't think it's a lull, I prefer to think of it as a spring cleaning. iOS 6 is great, but it has reached a visual saturation point, making it difficult to add more ideas.

Sometimes you need to step back in order to advance further. The Pentium 4 is a case in point.

I'm sure there will be ongoing refinement to the visual language, and will feel finished by the time iOS 7 ships. Then iOS 8 and 9 will be able to progressively layer new ideas into the new literal and metaphorical white space.

Re:iOS 7 looks familiar by Taylorious on Tuesday June 11, 2013 @04:08PM (#5864382)
I think it has more to do with the particular company. Namely, a company that brags about how original their designs/products and is very sue happy towards anyone who imitates them in the slightest. On top of that, they have a lot of fans who think of Apple as a master of UI and general design (I'm not saying they're wrong) and will associate the design Apple and not the others who spearheaded it.

I didn't listen to Apples presentation, so I don't know if they tooted their own horn on this new design scheme, but if I was a designer who had been working on interfaces similar to what Apple is switching to, I would still be pretty pissed off right now. Because, once people switch to iOS 7, the general public will perceive your design as "Apple like" or "Apple inspired."

Re:iOS 7 looks familiar by shurcooL on Tuesday June 11, 2013 @05:26PM (#5864832)
I couldn't care less how original or unoriginal something is, I mainly care about how good it is functionally and less so how pleasing it is visually. I wish more people paid attention to that rather than who created what first. All ideas are based on some other ideas to some degree.

I guess that's the difference. If Apple implemented something I created in their products, I'd be super happy that my idea is doing well and will benefit more people. I care about the ideas themselves, not about receiving credit.

Re:iOS 7 looks familiar by dman on Tuesday June 11, 2013 @03:47PM (#5864263)
http://gigaom.com/2005/09/20/redmond-start-your-photocopiers...

I dont get where people got this obsession from either.

Re:iOS 7 looks familiar by jljljl on Tuesday June 11, 2013 @04:06PM (#5864374)
The "Can't quite put my finger on it..." piece is in reference to a common catch-phrase for bloggers who have mocked Android, Samsung, and Microsoft for "copying" elements from iOS.

I agree the whole back and forth is a bit silly from both parties.

Edit: missed a word

Re:iOS 7 looks familiar by Steko on Tuesday June 11, 2013 @05:48PM (#5864936)
"elements from iOS"

Frequently seen re: MBA and iMac knock offs as well. It's hilarious and worth pointing out in both directions although I think the popular notion that one cancels out the other is false equivalence.

Re:iOS 7 looks familiar by jljljl on Tuesday June 11, 2013 @07:04PM (#5865305)
I agree that there are situations where the borrowing is much more blatant, and I don't think pointing out influences is a waste of time. Conversations along these lines tend to devolve into flame wars, however.
Re:iOS 7 looks familiar by coldtea on Wednesday June 12, 2013 @07:52AM (#5867589)
>The "Can't quite put my finger on it..." piece is in reference to a common catch-phrase for bloggers who have mocked Android, Samsung, and Microsoft for "copying" elements from iOS.

Only this is not a copy. It's just a different flat design, just as Windows also uses a flat design.

It doesn't copy the look of Windows Phone -- it just uses a similar flat visual language.

We cannot say the same for, e.g., MBA look-alikes that you cannot tell apart from 5 feet away.

It's like the difference between two manga comics by different artists (of course there are similarities: they used the same visual language) and a cheap rip-off of an animated series (e.g Power Rangers vs Powerful Rangers).

Re:iOS 7 looks familiar by jspark on Tuesday June 11, 2013 @03:43PM (#5864242)
Different people have different reasons for idolizing Apple, and one would be its role in the past half decade as the innovator, the leader, or the envelope-pusher. Taking cues from other companies' products goes against the refreshing originality we've enjoyed from Apple so much.

Disclaimer: I'm not saying I personally agree or even think this viewpoint is entirely true; just offering some insight.

Re:iOS 7 looks familiar by natmaster on Tuesday June 11, 2013 @06:54PM (#5865262)
There is nothing wrong with it. Unless of course you claim you revolutionized the space with your original designs - which is what Apple and co. do. I simply have a problem with people lying.
Re:iOS 7 looks familiar by shurcooL on Tuesday June 11, 2013 @06:33PM (#5865174)
Re:iOS 7 looks familiar by leoc on Wednesday June 12, 2013 @01:14AM (#5866627)
This Ars Technica piece http://arstechnica.com/apple/2013/06/the-global-influence-of... has a similar piece which is good too, pointing out that the app switcher seems to trace back to WebOS. Actually, the big, high and centred, skinny-lettered and unbordered time display on the lock screen always reminds me of some Sony Xperia lock screens, though maybe that's just me.
Re:iOS 7 looks familiar by bennyg on Tuesday June 11, 2013 @07:07PM (#5865321)
I like when people post a perspective like this. It's a lot more bold than to criticize every single thing. Stay humble, stay happy folks.
Re:iOS 7 looks familiar by hawleyal on Tuesday June 11, 2013 @03:40PM (#5864229)
No, it's like someone having a good idea, and someone else saying it was theirs.
Re:iOS 7 looks familiar by myko on Tuesday June 11, 2013 @03:43PM (#5864244)
When did this happen?
Re:iOS 7 looks familiar by dirkgently on Tuesday June 11, 2013 @07:27PM (#5865419)
When Apple patented Rounded Corners(TM)(R)(C) and declared it to be theirs.
Re:iOS 7 looks familiar by Volpe on Wednesday June 12, 2013 @04:20AM (#5867081)
When did this happen?

Or did you mean when they took out a design patent for a touch screen device of iPad like dimensions with very specific rounding on their corners that is reflected in the rest of their product line as well.

I'm pretty sure, that particular patent of Apple's is EXACTLY what design patents were invented for.

Disclaimer: I don't believe in the patent system at all, but the system exists, so the players play it.

Re:iOS 7 looks familiar by antimatter on Tuesday June 11, 2013 @03:51PM (#5864291)
Great post. This is what I keep thinking. I couldn't care less about these companies copying each other. If it benefits me as the user, then let them sue each other into oblivion or make any marketing claim about being innovative. Why do people take these things so personally?
Re:iOS 7 looks familiar by mtgx on Tuesday June 11, 2013 @06:35PM (#5865178)
Ideally that would be true - but try to tell that to Apple in 2010, 2011, and 2012.