Pressing online buttons would do more good if it were a submit on a EFF donation button. Probably more then banging on doors too.
Exactly.
This is why my activism site experiments with combining the two: seeking positive change by making symbolic donations to charity. The dollar amount of the donations made in a task's favor might actually help convey the weight of support. For example: http://btf.io/382 ("Pardon Edward Snowden")
In some ways I think online petitions have done some societal harm because people will always take the path of least resistance. If it's between clicking a button or actually going out and banging on doors to rally support, the button wins every time.