I can't be convinced it isn't happening at this point because we have evidence that it is from the government.
Much has been made of the carefully-worded "direct access to servers."
I really do doubt that Google gives the NSA a shell login. It's also completely truthful that Larry Page never heard of Prism (it was a TS/SCI program, of course he wouldn't know what it's called.)
But giving the NSA a special "Spy-only portal" which allows the NSA to type in "Show me everything in Mr. X's Google+ profile" is not direct access, and could be given within 5 minutes of getting the legal request.
It wouldn't be the first time that the 'trashy' newspaper broke a story.
Focus on the message, not the messenger.
They're actually quite decent when it comes to investigative news into the police, justice and the AIVD.
According to Larry Page Google does not give access to all your data within 5 minutes: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5860313