News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Rackspace Response to PRISM by chii on Tuesday June 11, 2013 @02:25AM (#5860096)
But the US of A has absolutely no obligation for the welbeing or privacy of any non-US citizen. if their data happens to be within US jurisdiction, the US gov't can do anything they like, provided that what they do is "lawful".

I m not saying PRISM is lawful (that remains to be seen?), but i think many non-US citizens are feeling too entitled to the protection of US law.

Re:Rackspace Response to PRISM by smackay on Tuesday June 11, 2013 @02:43AM (#5860159)
I don't think it's a sense of entitlement at all but rather decades of trust (and reliance) that was built after World War II when the only thing standing in the way of Soviet domination was the USA. It was always a little naive to think that the USA had everybody's best interest at heart but now it is now clear and unambiguously painted in big bold letters that the USA* are in it for themselves and only for themselves. All the talk of shared values and common purpose, spreading democracy and freedom, etc. etc. all rings rather hollow.

It's seems stupid that given recent events that the uproar over whether the US government is reading your Facebook posts has rammed the point home to many people but I guess this is just the final prod that woke a lot of people up.

*Purely from the perspective of the government. I've nothing but admiration (mostly) for large parts of the culture, attitude and hard work of the good citizens of the 50 states.

Re:Rackspace Response to PRISM by adventured on Tuesday June 11, 2013 @02:57AM (#5860202)
You're correct about the US of today, but you're making the common mistake of thinking the US of today has much in common with the US of 1950 (etc). We're a radically different nation today, even than what we were 15 or 30 years ago. This kind of rapid change isn't uncommon in our history, the US of 1840 was vastly different from the US of 1890.

There have been at least four or five major epochs for the US, which saw fairly substantial changes (good or bad) to the rule of law and social cohesion. We started as a constitutional republic and nearly laissez-faire capitalism; then we had a massive federal explosion post civil war, that saw the power of the states greatly diminished; we shifted to a mixed economy, welfare state with a heavy bent toward democracy; now we're speeding toward police state socialism with oligarchs, the facade of property rights, and blended government-corporations, aka fascism (or as some call it in our incarnation, corporatism).

Re:Rackspace Response to PRISM by einhverfr on Tuesday June 11, 2013 @02:36AM (#5860132)
Not quite. If you are in the US as a tourist, it doesn't matter what you have signed. They can't go and strip search you just because they felt like it.

What you have to realize is that 4th Amendment law is largely tied to searches for prosecution reasons and so usually the issue is "well, the 4th Amendment is violated and so to punish the government and give them the right incentives, we won't let them use the following set of evidence in their prosecution." It's really hard to make such rules effective regarding surveillance of foreigners conducted overseas.

Non-citizens in the US for whatever reason do have relevant liberties. This does not extend to say buying tv advertisements for candidates in elections, but it does extend to unreasonable searches and seizures. Non-citizens with no real ties to the US, and not in the US are different.

Re:Rackspace Response to PRISM by leoc on Tuesday June 11, 2013 @05:17AM (#5860606)
> Non-citizens with no real ties to the US, and not in the US are different.

But their US property is still protected. If I'm a Russian orthodontist in Minsk and I buy 500 shares of Google, the Fifth Amendment protects me having them expropriated by the US government even if I never go near the States. (IANAL, but I did check this one.) However if I open a Google Mail account then apparently (under current interpretations) I have no similar protections.

I can't say if this apparent discrepancy is actually legally justified, or not. Without even getting into the question of whether it's morally justified, it is going to come as a significant surprise to a lot of people, who have got used to the idea that they're largely protected by the US rule of law when they do business with the US. And one way or the other, it's reasonable to point out that Rackspace's Fourth Amendment-based reassurances seem to be (no doubt accidentally) crucially misleading to many or most of its customers.

Re:Rackspace Response to PRISM by einhverfr on Tuesday June 11, 2013 @05:31AM (#5860659)
Right, but one has a nexus to punitive power by the government and the other does not.
Re:Rackspace Response to PRISM by leoc on Tuesday June 11, 2013 @05:49AM (#5860715)
Not sure I follow you there actually. Is that a legal concept?
Re:Rackspace Response to PRISM by harywilke on Tuesday June 11, 2013 @03:12AM (#5860239)
The 5th and the 14th amendment cover all people, not just citizens. Here is an informative read on how and why and the history of the question of non-citizen rights. http://scholarship.law.georgetown.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?ar... Found this after a discussion of the rights of Boston Marathon suspects as non-citizens. Pretty much they have every right of a non-citizen, except the right to vote.
Re:Rackspace Response to PRISM by chii on Tuesday June 11, 2013 @04:20AM (#5860434)
that's an interesting read. I m about to reform my opinions (pending, since its quite a long read, and i've only skimmed it).