Re:Rand Paul: Big Brother Really Is Watching Us
by cpeterso on Monday June 10, 2013 @09:13PM
(#5858864)
I sometimes imagine what the US political system would look if all elected positions were "nonpartisan". What if voters had to listen to what politicians were actually saying without the blinders of "Red Team" or "Blue Team"?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Rand Paul: Big Brother Really Is Watching Us
by DamnYuppie on Monday June 10, 2013 @09:56PM
(#5859073)
I imagine it being quite wonderful. Imagine further if a bill could only contain 1 law in it and it had a built in shelf life of only 10-15 years and had to be renewed by a super majority vote in excess of 75%.
Re:Rand Paul: Big Brother Really Is Watching Us
by emidln on Monday June 10, 2013 @11:28PM
(#5859469)
This is an element of a couple Sci-Fi books I can think. Laws expire every N years (N=10 in the example that comes to mind first, that of the planet Sapphire in a novel series called Worlds Apart). This keeps the governing bodies busy enough renewing basic laws against theft/rape/murder/not paying taxes that no time is left for other things.
Re:Rand Paul: Big Brother Really Is Watching Us
by habitue on Monday June 10, 2013 @10:05PM
(#5859110)
> ...had to be renewed by a super majority vote in excess of 75%
While I'm sure some small government fans would say this is a good thing, the answer is that very little would get done. Symbolic gestures and the like would pass, but very little of real substance. It's commonly the case that most everyone agrees that something needs to be done, but often they disagree on what exactly needs to happen. You can see what happens in the senate when 60+ votes are needed to pass anything.
Re:Rand Paul: Big Brother Really Is Watching Us
by dnautics on Tuesday June 11, 2013 @01:09AM
(#5859862)
and if the government did less, we would feel empowered and obligated to do more ourselves, especially those things that don't necessarily need the barrel of a gun to get done. And if the government did less, then there would be little incentive for profiteers to try to capture government to profit at the end of a gun. I don't see what's so bad about this?
Re:Rand Paul: Big Brother Really Is Watching Us
by DamnYuppie on Tuesday June 11, 2013 @09:03AM
(#5861418)
I should have been clearer in that my underlying premise is that the government should be doing less.
Yet I am surprised that it was that element of my statement that people ran with. For me having a built in shelf life of a law is not nearly as important as having clearer legislation and the cessation of co-mingling unrelated laws into one bill.