Unless I myself run for office, I don't think I'll ever find a political party that closely aligns with my beliefs and also takes them seriously.
All parties start with one voice, regardless the exercise will bring clarity to the beliefs and values you hold most dear.
Suppose you want to vote for the Libertarian candidate but you'd prefer the Republican candidate to the Democratic one. By voting for the Libertarian, you "take" a vote from the Republican and make the Democrat's success more likely. (Or reverse the scenario: voting for a Green Party candidate hurts the Democratic candidate and gets you a Republican.)
Thus the system discourages you from expressing your true preference.
This is a major flaw in the most basic idea of democracy. All citizens, and especially all parties outside the Big Two, should work toward a better voting system.
One proposed system: http://rangevoting.org/
Libertarians are mostly pretty nice once you get to know them. Some of us are downright friendly at times.