Re:Government Secrets and the Need for Whistle-blowers
by ceautery on Monday June 10, 2013 @10:29AM
(#5854582)
We do register with the government at birth.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Government Secrets and the Need for Whistle-blowers
by josh2600 on Monday June 10, 2013 @10:31AM
(#5854611)
But you hardly provide tissue samples as you age. Your point has little to do with my argument :/.
Registration at birth is a choice we made because of the social values of planning. It's unlikely that those same people, as adults, would consent to yearly tissue exchange or other undignified spying apparati.
Re:Government Secrets and the Need for Whistle-blowers
by ceautery on Monday June 10, 2013 @11:02AM
(#5854859)
"Your point has little to do with my argument" - It's unclear what your argument is.
In addition to registering for an SSN, we provide images of ourselves as we age for driver's licenses, and some interactions with law enforcement end up with one's DNA being collected. Allegories to your dystopian state you feel people would balk at are already standard practice.
Bad stuff can be (and has been) done with this information (and that sucks), and as was stated above, so has exculpatory stuff (which is great).