Re:Panic Mode: Privacy Extension for Google Chrome
by passfree on Monday June 10, 2013 @05:11AM
(#5853192)
The only difference is that https-everywhere is trying to play nice and works only on some web sites that have been tested with the extension. It doesn't work "everywhere". Panic Mode, on the other hand, forces the user over SSL regardless if the other end supports or doesn't support SSL. This means that Panic Mode wont work for general browsing because you will quickly realise that most web sites do not support SSL or use self-signed certificates, etc.
However, my personal opinion is that sometimes it is better for things to be broken than to be sorry. If a web site breaks while Panic Mode is on and you care about your privacy, either something fishy is going on or the site is simply not good for this.
Panic Mode is more like poor man's VPN tunnel. Https-everywhere is good but can be fooled in some situations to leak sensitive information.
Re:Panic Mode: Privacy Extension for Google Chrome
by bifrost on Monday June 10, 2013 @04:40AM
(#5853102)
Uh, SSL doesn't guarantee privacy, it just guarantees transport privacy (usually). If the data is stored insecurely, you still are easily vulnerable. If you're using a trojaned SSL system (PRC, corporate, etc) this doesn't make you safer at all.
Re:Panic Mode: Privacy Extension for Google Chrome
by annnnd on Monday June 10, 2013 @08:34AM
(#5853886)
Actually, no - it is far worse than nothing. It makes you feel secure while you are not.
I don't understand this line of reasoning - why would HTTPS be the cure for the privacy problem? So you can post sensitive data through HTTPS to Gmail and it will be "private"?
Re:Panic Mode: Privacy Extension for Google Chrome
by annnnd on Tuesday June 11, 2013 @04:26AM
(#5860465)
My point was that it is neither a cure nor solution. It does of course help when combined with other means, but this plugin obviously can't supply those.
Re:Panic Mode: Privacy Extension for Google Chrome
by kryten on Monday June 10, 2013 @07:14AM
(#5853542)
The irony is that the product it's being plugged into is being issued by one of the companies at the middle of the PRISM thing and between the source code and the binary generation there is an unknown number of things that happen (please no-one spew the crap about Chrome being Chromium - it's not).
Secondarily, the root CA's are an easy target for the NSA, so MITM/re-transmission time.
And after all, those pesky terrorists are probably using pre-shared OTP's and any transport resulting in a completely secure channel anyway...
Re:Panic Mode: Privacy Extension for Google Chrome
by passfree on Monday June 10, 2013 @05:14AM
(#5853200)
Not great for general browsing indeed. However, it is indispensable for things that matter like banking, etc. I personally feel safer in some situation when I know that every single packet is forced over SSL and there is not even a single request that goes out over plain-text HTTP.
Re:Panic Mode: Privacy Extension for Google Chrome
by buster on Monday June 10, 2013 @05:17AM
(#5853207)
Yes sure, that's why i recommended the other extension (which i am using).
Because there are still a lot of sites out there that break or don't work over SSL at all.
Re:Panic Mode: Privacy Extension for Google Chrome
by passfree on Monday June 10, 2013 @05:21AM
(#5853217)
The problem with this approach is that due to the way cookies work you can still leak stuff like session identifiers if you forget to enlist certain subdomains and you are browsing other unprotected sites. The privacy in this case is as good as the weakest link.
I have multiple profiles under Google Chrome. One of them is for sensitive stuff where Panic Mode is installed and enabled always. I use it only for things that matter and it is not annoying me.
Re:Panic Mode: Privacy Extension for Google Chrome
by ankitoberoi on Monday June 10, 2013 @05:54AM
(#5853293)
Not very useful. Only secures your data when it's transferring over the network. Most of the website I use and have my private data over, are already forced https.
The problem of your Service Provider giving private data access to the government, still remains.
https://www.eff.org/https-everywhere
However, my personal opinion is that sometimes it is better for things to be broken than to be sorry. If a web site breaks while Panic Mode is on and you care about your privacy, either something fishy is going on or the site is simply not good for this.
Panic Mode is more like poor man's VPN tunnel. Https-everywhere is good but can be fooled in some situations to leak sensitive information.
I don't understand this line of reasoning - why would HTTPS be the cure for the privacy problem? So you can post sensitive data through HTTPS to Gmail and it will be "private"?
Secondarily, the root CA's are an easy target for the NSA, so MITM/re-transmission time.
And after all, those pesky terrorists are probably using pre-shared OTP's and any transport resulting in a completely secure channel anyway...
It's all ridiculous.
It let's you surf over SSL but has a black and a whitelist.
I have multiple profiles under Google Chrome. One of them is for sensitive stuff where Panic Mode is installed and enabled always. I use it only for things that matter and it is not annoying me.
Here is an example: http://blog.websecurify.com/2013/03/how-to-improve-your-brow...
The problem of your Service Provider giving private data access to the government, still remains.
If they can compromise/coerce/control a root CA, then everything is largely moot.